WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

    Two nights before the championship game -- do you have to remind yourself who is playing, like I did? -- what do people think of the new 20-team format? My reaction has been lukewarm at best – though obviously having lost in the 1st round took some luster away. But regardless, having the play in games reminded me of starting a car in winter… takes a long time for it to warm up. And while I should probably withhold my opinion on the title game until surveying the crowd on Friday, it seems like an absolute disaster. First off, the three week layoff has stunted all momentum. Worse yet, an hour after the game kicks off, it will be “competing” – lets not lie, there is no competition – for air time with the Cotton Bowl… in the same metropolitan area no less!! I thought the point of moving the game back was to generate more excitement/prestige? And instead its pitted against one of the most historic bowls in football? Wow.

    I get that we were just on the outside looking in on the playoffs a few times and could no doubt ultimately benefit from those extra four slots… but was the system so broke it needed fixing?

    Thoughts?

  • #2
    Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

    The 20 team format is fine, but I'm not a big fan of the 3 week layoff. It's like you take everything that is good about FCS (playoffs) and mix it with the bad of FBS (long layoff).

    I'm a big beliver in momentum and that layoff just kills any momentum you may have. Some may disagree, but I use Wisconsin as an example. They were rolling at the end of the season and then BAM, you take a month off.

    Twenty team format... good... long break until title game... bad.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

      Originally posted by Barnstormer View Post
      The 20 team format is fine, but I'm not a big fan of the 3 week layoff. It's like you take everything that is good about FCS (playoffs) and mix it with the bad of FBS (long layoff).

      I'm a big beliver in momentum and that layoff just kills any momentum you may have. Some may disagree, but I use Wisconsin as an example. They were rolling at the end of the season and then BAM, you take a month off.

      Twenty team format... good... long break until title game... bad.
      I believe Coach Farley likes the layoff. More preparation time, more time to heal injuries.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

        Could it be that the excitement seems to have dwindled because we ourselves have not gotten to play in over a month?? I'm sure if we were actually involved in the game this week -- excitement would be at an all-time high. And more people would have the potential of going to the game with more time to plan and prepare.
        "...the Northern Iowa men's basketball team reached the ultimate highs before hitting a devastating low. Unexpected success, followed by unimaginable failure. And they owned it -- all of it -- for the world to see. Like men. Like leaders. Like champions -- in a way no tournament bracket could ever define."

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

          it def felt like the playoffs have been going on forever. i'd actually completely forgotten about the championship game until i was scrolling thru the program guide looking to see what bowl games were on this week and saw it. as a coach and your in the nc game, i think youre in favor of it's an extra several weeks of practice....as a fan i think it terrible, finish up in december....

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

            Anne & Born... Both good points. Coaches would totally love the prep time.

            Also, I guess it would give a team that is maybe not playing up to their potential some time to rest and prepare (see Iowa) Though it gives your players more time to get into trouble... (see Iowa.)

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

              I'd be okay with the three week layoff if it was going to buy the FCS some actual exposure. However now that it is the same night, time, and city as the cotton bowl, it absolutely sucks. Big thumbs down on the current arrangement.
              If computers ruled college basketball the way they do football, we'd have skipped all this March Madness monotony and just waited a month for the Kansas-Kentucky title game. And watched Northern Iowa play Cornell in the Poulan Weedeater Bowl. ~ Dwight Perry The Seattle Times

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                The twenty team format is stupid. To be the auto bid from the number 2 conference in the country and have to play in the play in round / not have a first week bye, when teams that got 2nd and 3rd place in the conference do is absurd. We, more than anyone should be against expansion, we did just fine without it, it is the teams that didn't that needed it, NDSU, MSU, etc...
                Illinois State Fan at a St. Louis White Castle 3:45AM Saturday March 6th:

                "White Castle?" "more like Black Castle..."

                You stay classy Redbirds.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                  Originally posted by Born-a-Panther View Post
                  Could it be that the excitement seems to have dwindled because we ourselves have not gotten to play in over a month?? I'm sure if we were actually involved in the game this week -- excitement would be at an all-time high. And more people would have the potential of going to the game with more time to plan and prepare.
                  Obviously, yes, I'd be excited no matter when, where or who we played. But I'm not who the FCS should be concerned about because I'll go wherever my team goes and watch the championship game regardless. But at the same time, we got 8,000 plus to travel to Chatty on six days notice. I can't imagine a significantly higher number going due to more break. Especially because by that time most kids are back in school, people are looking at heavy credit card bills due to the holidays, etc.

                  Of the two big decisions -- to expand and move the date -- I just dont see the latter as a wise one.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                    I would like to see all auto-bids skip the play-in game or else go to 32 teams and get rid of the first round bye.

                    Keep the 3 week delay to the title game.
                    "I think they're very good," Farley said of the preseason top 25 Hawkeyes. "But so are we."

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                      who is playing? I was wondering why I hadn't heard anything about this before christmas break.

                      I like the 20 teams, but agree a conference champion should not have to play in the "play-in" round. They should get a bye in the 1st round. Make whoever is the at-large teams battle it out in the 1st round.

                      I would like the championship game to come on a night during all the BCS bowl games. Not on the same night as the Cotton Bowl. Play it on a Thursday night or even the Saturday before the national Championship. Any other time than Friday night splitting time with the Cotton Bowl. Poor Planning

                      Can anyone tell me why they have so many bowl games after the 1st of the year? Jesus its like its never gonna end, we have the "Fight Hunger Bowl" and some other no-name bowls. FBS needs a play-off right away, these bowls are getting out of hand!

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                        Originally posted by PantherHawk View Post
                        Can anyone tell me why they have so many bowl games after the 1st of the year? Jesus its like its never gonna end, we have the "Fight Hunger Bowl" and some other no-name bowls. FBS needs a play-off right away, these bowls are getting out of hand!
                        Even with a 4 or 8-team playoff the bowls aren't going anywhere as 60+ teams still need a "reward" for going 6-6; but I do wish there was some mandate that forced them all into that Dec ~20-Jan 1 window, save for maybe the BCS games.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                          Originally posted by jegbomb52 View Post
                          The twenty team format is stupid. To be the auto bid from the number 2 conference in the country and have to play in the play in round / not have a first week bye, when teams that got 2nd and 3rd place in the conference do is absurd. We, more than anyone should be against expansion, we did just fine without it, it is the teams that didn't that needed it, NDSU, MSU, etc...
                          I really wouldn't consider the MVFC to be the #2 conference. At least not this past year. A very unimpressive non-conference schedule.

                          Playoff expansion didn't hurt UNI FB. With the way they played at the end of the season, they would have been just as likely to lose in the first round of the 16 team playoffs (if not more so).

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                            I, too, haven't really given much care about the FCS title game.
                            But that has nothing to do with the change in format, as I never really paid much attention to it in previous years when UNI didn't make the playoffs, or lost in the first round or two.
                            (nor do I really care about the BCS "championship" game)

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: What do you think of the 20-team playoff format now?

                              Originally posted by JayJ79 View Post
                              I really wouldn't consider the MVFC to be the #2 conference. At least not this past year. A very unimpressive non-conference schedule.

                              Playoff expansion didn't hurt UNI FB. With the way they played at the end of the season, they would have been just as likely to lose in the first round of the 16 team playoffs (if not more so).
                              No doubt. It wasn't just the end of the season, either. I don't recall UNI beating any very good teams in 2010.

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X