WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

    Originally posted by Trapped in California View Post
    Is this a chicken and egg thing? Is Rennie couldn't make the passes, why call them?

    SFA's QB did not have any great arm strength (that I saw). However, he absolutely knew the routes/timing of his receivers and was extremely accurate. I don't believe either of those comments could have been attributed to Rennie last year. If that changes come August, it would provide serious upside for the expectations of the season.
    From what it sounds like, he hasn't really made strong strides in that department. Granted, it was a spring game, and he wasn't in a heck of a lot, but it didn't sound like a huge improvement. However, I'd love for him to prove me wrong.
    Raised a Hawkeye, Panther by choice.






    Comment


    • #17
      Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

      Originally posted by Trapped in California View Post
      Is this a chicken and egg thing? Is Rennie couldn't make the passes, why call them?

      SFA's QB did not have any great arm strength (that I saw). However, he absolutely knew the routes/timing of his receivers and was extremely accurate. I don't believe either of those comments could have been attributed to Rennie last year. If that changes come August, it would provide serious upside for the expectations of the season.
      Again I don't disagree with that statement. However, it was pretty clear the routes they called for Rennie to throw last year weren't working all that well. Calling some slants, drags, boot legs with a flood pattern for the WR, etc... couldn't have been any worse at times.

      The other problem that should be fixed this year with developing the timing with the WR is the practice snaps. Last year Rennie and Davis split the snaps close to 50/50 in practice I'd bet. Neither one had any clue on the timing of each WR routes. With Rennie being "TBMOC" this year I'd hope that problem is solved.

      Comment


      • #18
        Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

        I would say that another significant change over last year is that there is a viable 2nd (or 3rd) running back after Carlos. Taking nothing away from Strathman, cause I loved his attitude, but the players on the depth chart are an upgrade in the ball carrying department. No knowledge about the blocking, etc.

        Comment


        • #19
          Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

          Originally posted by Trapped in California View Post
          No knowledge about the blocking, etc.
          We return, what, four of 5 starters on the line, right? Should be improved
          Top ten UNI football plays from 2001-2011

          Comment


          • #20
            Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

            I was referring the players behind Carlos, this year versus last, to be more specific than my first post.

            Comment


            • #21
              Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

              I really enjoyed the fact that they listed our spotlight game as South Dakota State, I wonder what Bison fans think of this?

              Also nice find Moose!

              Comment


              • #22
                Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

                Originally posted by UNI83 View Post
                Again I don't disagree with that statement. However, it was pretty clear the routes they called for Rennie to throw last year weren't working all that well. Calling some slants, drags, boot legs with a flood pattern for the WR, etc... couldn't have been any worse at times.

                The other problem that should be fixed this year with developing the timing with the WR is the practice snaps. Last year Rennie and Davis split the snaps close to 50/50 in practice I'd bet. Neither one had any clue on the timing of each WR routes. With Rennie being "TBMOC" this year I'd hope that problem is solved.
                First I was and always will be TBMOC

                But I agree Rennie should be much improved over last year in passing. The coaches should be much improved in play calling that highlights Rennie's strengths.

                Comment


                • #23
                  Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

                  Not to get into an argument, but I assume our coaches had reasons for calling the plays that they did. They are not dumb - they are certainly smarter than me - and I'm sure by several games in to the season, they knew what they had. Sometimes plays have to be called to keep the D honest.

                  I know some plays looked brutal last year, especially on 3rd down, but they were good enough to win the conference. Hopefully we learned from our last two games. They are still just 18-22 year old guys. The coaches are there for every practice, and spend practically every waking moment thinking about football. They know the options. When Bill Salmon called the play to win at Western Kentucky, he was a genius.

                  It is instructive that typically the only FB assistant that is questioned by the fans/media is the offensive coordinator/play caller. Doesn't the defensive coordinator ever make some questionable calls?

                  Also, as a fan, I like to talk about & watch the skill positions. But I know that really it comes down to the offensive line. I hope that Coach Nelson starts doing his job this year.

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

                    Originally posted by '70 Grad View Post
                    Not to get into an argument, but I assume our coaches had reasons for calling the plays that they did. They are not dumb - they are certainly smarter than me - and I'm sure by several games in to the season, they knew what they had. Sometimes plays have to be called to keep the D honest.

                    I know some plays looked brutal last year, especially on 3rd down, but they were good enough to win the conference. Hopefully we learned from our last two games. They are still just 18-22 year old guys. The coaches are there for every practice, and spend practically every waking moment thinking about football. They know the options. When Bill Salmon called the play to win at Western Kentucky, he was a genius.

                    It is instructive that typically the only FB assistant that is questioned by the fans/media is the offensive coordinator/play caller. Doesn't the defensive coordinator ever make some questionable calls?

                    Also, as a fan, I like to talk about & watch the skill positions. But I know that really it comes down to the offensive line. I hope that Coach Nelson starts doing his job this year.
                    Good post 70 and you are correct about the line the only thing is that Coach Nelson is one of the best line coaches in the country.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

                      The Veer is a great offense...

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

                        If Rennie develops an accurate short pass for the slant, WR screen, and post then we'll be having a very high octane offense this year. It would be pretty hard to stop when coupled with our excellent backs. Let's all hope he continues to develop over the summer (and maybe grow a few inches).

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Re: TSN: FCS Top 10 QBs

                          Originally posted by '70 Grad View Post
                          Not to get into an argument, but I assume our coaches had reasons for calling the plays that they did. They are not dumb - they are certainly smarter than me - and I'm sure by several games in to the season, they knew what they had. Sometimes plays have to be called to keep the D honest.

                          I know some plays looked brutal last year, especially on 3rd down, but they were good enough to win the conference. Hopefully we learned from our last two games. They are still just 18-22 year old guys. The coaches are there for every practice, and spend practically every waking moment thinking about football. They know the options. When Bill Salmon called the play to win at Western Kentucky, he was a genius.

                          It is instructive that typically the only FB assistant that is questioned by the fans/media is the offensive coordinator/play caller. Doesn't the defensive coordinator ever make some questionable calls?

                          Also, as a fan, I like to talk about & watch the skill positions. But I know that really it comes down to the offensive line. I hope that Coach Nelson starts doing his job this year.
                          Not saying I disagree, but the conference wasn't very good as a whole last year. I recall most squads trying to break in a new group of guys, but that could just be my bias. I think last year was impressive because Farley got the conference title in a year that the team was supposed to struggle. This year the team could expect people to be a little bit more critical. Personally, I'd be happy with a decent playoff run...

                          "Once it starts, it never ends."
                          -Eldon Miller

                          Comment

                          Working...
                          X