WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

My Thoughts Western Illinois

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • My Thoughts Western Illinois

    QB: Tirrell was the best I have ever saw him. 10-14 for 142 and two TD's is what I like to see. He should have been 11-14 for 239 but that was really the only flaw along with trying to force the ball once to Collins but he has proven he is a capable passer which will allow him to run more. I do fault the coaching staff for not pulling him earlier, first off you are risking injury in a game that is already in hand, and secondly give Lanpher a series with the #1's to see how he does.

    Grade: A-

    RB: David Johnson looked great. My friend said to me, "It doesn't even look like he is even running that fast" and it doesn't he just glides. He had great vision for the game, and can always catch the ball well out of the backfield. Also found out after the game with his interview with Gary and Petey that he is a triplet, which is kind of interesting. I think my favorite thing was that he only lost yardage on one carry the whole game. Carlos looked good while he was in there, but I really question if he needed to play. He aggravated the injury again, but I think he will be fine as he was walking fine after the game.

    Grade: A

    WR/TE: This group did a very nice job of getting open and catching the ball, which is what they are supposed to do, but the thing I am always the most impressed with is the groups ability to block down field. They do understand well that we are a run first team and they do what is necessary to help the team. I also liked the fact that all three freshman were on the field at the same time many times throughout the game, and all look good.

    Grade: B+

    OL: This group is continuing to grow as a unit very little pressure was put on Tirrell which will lead to more success in the passing game. When you have two 100 yard rushers that is directly on the line. There were a few times they did seem to get a little over extended on technique (loosing balance) which they won't be able to do against the top tier teams of the league, but over all good game by all.

    Grade: A-

    DL: This is another group that continues to get better each week, which is kind of scary. They are also building a little bit more depth in there. We know what we are going to get with the Boothby's ans Branch's of the world but I was really impressed with Augie, Mac, Jepsen, and Tim Clark, along with the two big RS freshmen that got in there some. We do need to continue to grow this depth for later on in the season against better teams, where we can keep sending fresh guys against a worn out OL without much drop off in talent. Does anyone know why Eilert wasn't at the game?

    Grade: A-

    LB: This group is one of the best in the nation, their speed and ability to cover and defend sideline to sideline is amazing. They also seem to be some of the smartest linebackers that we have had at UNI. For this game I think this would describe the way that they played. Fast, Physical, and Smart. There were a few runs that I am sure they were upset about, but as a whole they were able to shut down what Western wanted to do.

    Grade: A-

    DB: This group is also very talented but at sometimes seem to have some lapses in thinking. One of Western more successful passing plays, it appeared that we shifted into a cover 3 but one of our corners didn't apparently get the message and left the receiver wide open. Now again they are always able to recover very well but we do need to clean that sort of stuff up.

    Grade: B

    Special Teams: This group didn't have that great of a game, missed field goal, and one bad punt, but also one punt block. The field goal doesn't concern me a whole lot because I think that Sieversten can make it 7 or 8 times out of 10 where Billy would have consistently choked on that kick. The punt was more do to a short snap and try to get it off quick. The one thing I want to see improved is fair catching punts instead of letting them go so much.

    Grade: B-

    Other thoughts: I thought that the # of people at the game was great, but the game did get rather boring taking the crowd out of it kind of early. The interlude should be done at a different time of the game, and given more time. The UNI flags presentation was terrible, first of all they should be done right in front of the team, and secondly they should be done by the Panther Pep Crew.

    Players of Game:

    Offense: Tirrell Rennie, with a close second to David Johnson
    Defense: August Hadenfeldt

  • #2
    Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

    I second everything you just said....especially FAIR CATCHING PUNTS!!! Drives me nuts because 9 times out of 10 it seems to bounce not in our favor

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

      punting out of one's own endzone is always extra tough. sometimes you don't even have your usual distance behind the line, and you have to worry about not stepping on the endline. Plus on that particular punt, the snap wasn't the greatest and the punter had to basically pick it up off the ground, which messes with timing.


      as for the punt returns, some of those punts had fairly low tragectory and would have required a scramble to get into position to catch it, which means risking a turnover. Better to give up some field position than to muff a punt and give the ball to the other team.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

        Eilert in the doghouse - don't know the reason - dropped to scout team.

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

          Originally posted by djb View Post
          Eilert in the doghouse - don't know the reason - dropped to scout team.
          I noticed that he was not out there Saturday. That's strange. Also, I am still very curious about Andre Martin. I thought that he was our best defensive back last year and was a real playmaker for us. Yet this year, he barely sees the field.

          As far as the game goes, tremendous performance by the team. Tirrell was fantastic, Johnson was amazing, the D played well. We went out and really stomped a team that we should have stomped.

          Only gripe I have about the game was a) Why did we play Carlos in a game where he clearly was not needed? It appears that he tweaked his ankle again in one of the three plays that he was in. Really dumb.

          And b) We should have taken the #1 offense out of the game earlier. I was hoping that Lanpher could get some snaps, so we could see what he's got and for him to get some real game experience. It was stupid to be still running Tirrell when we were up by 35 points.
          UNI FIGHT

          Originally posted by 9YRPLAN
          iowa sucks, fran sucks, their schedule sucks, iowa fans suck

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

            One thought that I had was that I really wish we had a receiver like WIU had (I think #88 or 87??). Big / huge kid with very good hands. I think we have some of the fastest receivers in the league, but they just don't seem to be lock solid on catching the ball consistently.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

              Yeah I was wondering about Eilert and Andre Martin as well.

              I really thought both would be playing big minutes.

              Also wondering about Gacke #35 at LB. Thought we'd see him on the field more. He played some as a Freshman last year and looked good. Not sure he ever made it on the field. Maybe he's not healthy.

              It really struck me how much depth UNI has. We've got strong players at a number of positions who are not getting much time on the field. I'm sure that depth will be tested.

              Noticed Kromah got some time at DT...#97. He's a big, big man but needs to get off the ball quicker. Made me appreciate more the unique talent that Boothby is with is combination of mass and speed.
              Winning is more fun than losing.

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

                Originally posted by Blue42 View Post
                Also wondering about Gacke #35 at LB. Thought we'd see him on the field more. He played some as a Freshman last year and looked good. Not sure he ever made it on the field. Maybe he's not healthy.
                I think I remember Farley saying something about Gacke having gotten injured in the preseason (or maybe it was ISU week). For some reason, I'm thinking back injury.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

                  A lot of people will wonder why the 1st stringers were not pulled eariler. Fact is that I knew near the end of the 3rd Q when we got the ball back that it would be their last drive. As a coach, you let them have one mroe before the 4th quarter. Just happened that that last drive took 7-8 minutes and crossed over into the 4th Q. A part of that may go back to conservative play calling. Yea we were up big 31-3 but 31-3 or 38-3 and 41 or 45-3 seem the same to me and not running up the score. You want to get your starters out after their last drive. make their last drive memorable jmo
                  Last edited by Purrrrrfect; 09-26-2011, 12:05 PM.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

                    I only said that because the game was clearly in hand at the start of the last drive of Q3. Carlos had already left the game with an ankle injury of some sort. Then Tirrel took a pretty good shot making a first down, crossing mid field.

                    The season goes as Tirrell goes. He's gonna take enough shots during the regular season - why not minimize that and get the backup QB some PT with the 1st team?

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

                      I completely agree, I was just giving you the reasoning as to why it would prob. went that way.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: My Thoughts Western Illinois

                        My Thoughts...Western is not a very good team this year.
                        Go Panthers!

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        X