Should Carnes remain starter?

[Geno4UNI]

Re: Should Carnes remain starter?

I think we won today more in spite of Carnes than because of Carnes. He just can't throw the ball well enough, wind or no wind. If it weren't for 7 early point after the fumble on the 2, a healthy type of DJ game and a huge MSU wide open dropped pass we would have needed a better game from our QB than Carnes is capable of IMO. We won the game but I wouldn't say WE beat Them. MSU was very generous today. Don't get me wrong with the way this season has gone I will take a win any way we can get one. Think we need to win this one by bigger margin if we want the Selection Committee to think we are back to early season form.

[JayJ79]

Re: Should Carnes remain starter?

meh, I don't think a bigger margin would have really made that much of a difference, unless it was a 20+ point blowout, and that was unlikely. a win is a win.

['70 Grad]

Re: Should Carnes remain starter?

He fit at least one important pass into a small window. Some others were not even close. (Assuming it was not a receiver problem.) However, his completion percentage is pretty decent & they are calling more kinds of pass plays with him than a few weeks back when he had to jump in the breech. Made some yards with his feet & was a threat on the option (giving the RBs more space). Good thing we have him.