WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

    Virginia Tech for Virginia.

    Comment


    • #17
      Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

      Originally posted by Blue42 View Post
      A school that hasn't fielded a FB team in 30 years finds the thought of playing FCS football highly disappointing? That's rich.

      There's doing it...and there's talking about it. You're light years from fielding a team that could hang with the top 1/2 of the MVFC....so when you can, then come back and tell us about your disappointment.
      Not sure where the disdain comes from here, but yes, Wichita would find FCS football, long term, to be highly disappointing. I'm sorry if you can't comprehend that most fans here want to compete at the highest level. They want to have another avenue to be better than the two schools to our north. These are fans that have never watched FCS football and the majority won't get into it. Older fans watched Wichita host other FBS schools when we played. Since we dropped it, they've watched KU, KSU, OU, OSU and will support Wichita if we're at that level.

      FCS will get fans just because it's football, but an average FBS team would draw twice as much as a championship FCS team here. FCS isn't on the football radar in Kansas. It's pretty simple.

      I'm not bad mouthing FCS as I'd go to the games, but in the grand scheme of football at Wichita, it would be a poor decision and would fail to capitalize on what football could really bring to the city.
      WheatShockers.com

      Comment


      • #18
        Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

        Originally posted by DomeIsHome View Post
        Huh? Playing in the toughest conference, having guaranteed home and home's with the nation's best, and have the best shot at the playoff wouldn't do more for WSU?


        Come on man, what are we even DOING out here man?
        So you really believe 2 or 3 years in MVFC would really do more than being independent? But as I've said previously, and obviously ignored by you, those comments are predicated on only being FCS for a short time and that depends on what we're hearing from others when this decision gets made. Or what kind of time frame we're looking at for the next wave of realignment. It completely changes if we're looking at a decade or more in FCS, but if that's the case my previous comments about support remain true.

        I'm sorry if you take these comments so personally because they're obviously not directed at UNI or FCS in that sort of way. But you and Blue obviously have your own agenda and have no desire to have any sort of respectful discussion over the matter like the rest of us have.
        WheatShockers.com

        Comment


        • #19
          Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

          Originally posted by SubGod22 View Post
          So you really believe 2 or 3 years in MVFC would really do more than being independent? But as I've said previously, and obviously ignored by you, those comments are predicated on only being FCS for a short time and that depends on what we're hearing from others when this decision gets made. Or what kind of time frame we're looking at for the next wave of realignment. It completely changes if we're looking at a decade or more in FCS, but if that's the case my previous comments about support remain true.

          I'm sorry if you take these comments so personally because they're obviously not directed at UNI or FCS in that sort of way. But you and Blue obviously have your own agenda and have no desire to have any sort of respectful discussion over the matter like the rest of us have.
          I think you are right. You guys would be better off as an independent. You could schedule light the first few years to create a winning atmosphere and then increase the SOS over time. I think that's what Old Dominion did and it was successful until they moved up.
          Selling a lot of old UNI stuff here: http://www.panthernation.com/showthread.php?t=65762

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by TravelingPanther View Post
            I think you are right. You guys would be better off as an independent. You could schedule light the first few years to create a winning atmosphere and then increase the SOS over time. I think that's what Old Dominion did and it was successful until they moved up.


            ODU was CAA from the start. They have been a large meh, boarder line damn bad, since moving FBS.

            Comment


            • #21
              Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

              Originally posted by SubGod22 View Post
              So you really believe 2 or 3 years in MVFC would really do more than being independent? .
              Yes look at those Dakota schools. Complete jokes the first year by year 3 complete differences.

              UNI fans have seen it.


              ALSO:
              Just remember Creighturd got what they wanted. Beat up the Big East with a Valley team, but no one has heard anything from them since Dougie left.

              The Shocker have been shining so bright in the Valley and nationally lately the fanbase probably haven't noticed.

              Be careful what you wish for.

              Comment


              • #22
                Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                Originally posted by UNIDebo View Post
                V tech and a d2 or 3 from Vermont I believe
                Oops, had a case of the V's I guess, I meant to ask about Maryland.

                Comment


                • #23
                  Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                  Vermont is the Middlebury College Panthers of all things.

                  Maryland is Navy, but I've never seen that logo. The N part yes, but not the bull or whatever it is.

                  There are teams in Iowa with better records than UNI if you go all divisions. This must be just division I programs unless a state doesn't have any, then they go down a division.
                  GO PANTHERS!

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                    So WSU is going to get into a p5 conference via independent fcs to mountain west fbs to what? Big 12 expansion? Wsu does zero for tv market which is all they care about in football.

                    If quality mattered Boise st would be in a p5 conference.

                    There is a better chance football is dropped as a college sport because of head trauma than there is of WSU getting a p5 invite.

                    If their goal is only non p5 fbs football they are wasting their time. There is no pot of gold at that level

                    My guess is somebody with more money than brains is willing to spend a fortune with the pipe dream of p5 football and nobody is going to commit professional suicide by telling that person they are wasting their time. .
                    Last edited by run&blade; 06-12-2016, 09:33 PM.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                      Originally posted by claw View Post
                      ODU was CAA from the start. They have been a large meh, boarder line damn bad, since moving FBS.
                      They were independent for 2 seasons.

                      First season schedule:
                      Selling a lot of old UNI stuff here: http://www.panthernation.com/showthread.php?t=65762

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                        Originally posted by SubGod22 View Post
                        So you really believe 2 or 3 years in MVFC would really do more than being independent? But as I've said previously, and obviously ignored by you, those comments are predicated on only being FCS for a short time and that depends on what we're hearing from others when this decision gets made. Or what kind of time frame we're looking at for the next wave of realignment. It completely changes if we're looking at a decade or more in FCS, but if that's the case my previous comments about support remain true.

                        I'm sorry if you take these comments so personally because they're obviously not directed at UNI or FCS in that sort of way. But you and Blue obviously have your own agenda and have no desire to have any sort of respectful discussion over the matter like the rest of us have.
                        I'm not against WSU re-implementing their football program, but if you actually think that being an FCS independant is better than playing in (by far) the best FCS conference for even two seasons, than I don't know what to tell you. There aren't any (current or future) FCS programs that could sustain anything longer than two years as an independent, but since that's not the goal for WSU I guess it doesn't matter. Side note - Does anybody know if you can spend just two years in FCS ball? I might be thinking of the transitional period after getting to FBS. As UNIDebo said above, only look at NDSU to see what two or three years can get you playing against the best competition out there.

                        Everybody would LOVE to be FBS/Power 5. More money, more players, more recognizable opponents, better home games (probably), better crowds for those home games, more money.

                        And personally I don't really care what WSU does. I don't think we'll be seeing WSU fielding a FBS football team for at least 10 years (if at all), and I don't think we'll see WSU football in general for at least five. I don't have an agenda, I'm just a guy on a message board, just like everybody else.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                          Originally posted by run&blade View Post
                          So WSU is going to get into a p5 conference via independent fcs to mountain west fbs to what? Big 12 expansion? Wsu does zero for tv market which is all they care about in football.

                          If quality mattered Boise st would be in a p5 conference.

                          There is a better chance football is dropped as a college sport because of head trauma than there is of WSU getting a p5 invite.

                          If their goal is only non p5 fbs football they are wasting their time. There is no pot of gold at that level

                          My guess is somebody with more money than brains is willing to spend a fortune with the pipe dream of p5 football and nobody is going to commit professional suicide by telling that person they are wasting their time. .
                          No one associated with WSU in any official capacity is thinking anything about a P5 invite. Essentially no one in the fan base thinks otherwise either, but I'd imagine you could find a tiny sliver of uninformed, embarrassing, fringe WSU fans somewhere who have that pipe dream. We all have our special idiots.

                          The problem is, unfortunately, the MVC as a whole is not committed to athletic excellence. I'm not even sure they are committed to maintaining status quo, to be perfectly honest. The point of WSU bringing back football is not so that we can become the NDSU of FCS or the Boise or Houston of G5 FBS, it is simply so that we can perhaps grab a lifeline to get out of the sinking ship that is the MVC, before the vacuum of it going under takes WSU with it. That's it, and you can find quotes from our University President saying just that in a more diplomatic fashion.

                          Additionally, WSU is a bad fit quantitatively in the MVC:

                          *Even though we don't have a football component currently, our athletic budget is the largest in the MVC. If we added football and funded it at the average rate of MWC/AAC schools, the margin would become proportionally quite large.

                          *Our MBB budget is roughly twice as large as MVC number two, and close to three times the size of MVC average.

                          *Our endowment fund is again a couple of times larger than MVC number two, and multiples larger than MVC average. (In the context of the MVC publics - apples and oranges to compare endowments of public and private schools obviously.)

                          *Our research revenues are literally exponentially larger than most of the rest of the conference. I haven't looked it up in a while, but last I saw MVC number two in this regard was a long, long ways down from WSU.

                          *WSU is also in a level of Carnegie Classification that only ISUr shares in the MVC. What this means if you've never heard of the above is that WSU and ISUr are considered research universities, with the rest of the conference being more like large liberal arts colleges.

                          None of this is to take a crap on any one MVC school necessarily, especially UNI which seems to consistently do the most with what is provided. The point is simply that WSU's house is arguable and very possibly the largest and most valuable in a declining neighborhood, and we just want to move to a neighborhood where we can be the average (or even below average) home comparatively. If we make this move we'd hopefully also be moving ourselves out of a flood plain.

                          Ultimately, WSU might just be stuck in the MVC due to football and geography issues, but I'd bet good money this sorry conference is going to be on the wrong side of the demarcation line when the big shake-up happens, whereas conferences like the MWC, AAC, BE, and A10 might very well be safe.
                          Last edited by SHOCKvalue; 06-13-2016, 11:26 AM.

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                            Originally posted by DomeIsHome View Post
                            I'm not against WSU re-implementing their football program, but if you actually think that being an FCS independant is better than playing in (by far) the best FCS conference for even two seasons, than I don't know what to tell you. There aren't any (current or future) FCS programs that could sustain anything longer than two years as an independent, but since that's not the goal for WSU I guess it doesn't matter. Side note - Does anybody know if you can spend just two years in FCS ball? I might be thinking of the transitional period after getting to FBS. As UNIDebo said above, only look at NDSU to see what two or three years can get you playing against the best competition out there.

                            Everybody would LOVE to be FBS/Power 5. More money, more players, more recognizable opponents, better home games (probably), better crowds for those home games, more money.

                            And personally I don't really care what WSU does. I don't think we'll be seeing WSU fielding a FBS football team for at least 10 years (if at all), and I don't think we'll see WSU football in general for at least five. I don't have an agenda, I'm just a guy on a message board, just like everybody else.
                            From start up to FBS there is a minimum of 2 playing seasons to get there, if you have an invite before starting the program. It also takes a few years to even actually get a program.

                            UTSA and South Alabama are the two best examples. Both went through 4-5 years of building up the back end of the program before fielding their first teams.

                            UTSA started the process in 06 and fielded their first team in 2011. They were considered a transition until 2014

                            South Alabama got approval for football in 2007 and started play in 2009. South Alabama had quite a few roadbumps they hid behind the "we're doing just fine" curtain from having that kind of turn around. South Alabama was considered transitional from 2009-2012. 2013 was their first full FBS member season

                            The reality is WSU, if they get BOR approval for football tomorrow, is a minimum 2 years from football taking the field (likely 3). They are then 4 years from actually being an FBS member. That means WSU is, at the very earliest, an FBS program in 2022

                            With an invite accepted tomorrow UNI could be FBS by 2018
                            Last edited by claw; 06-13-2016, 12:35 PM.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                              Originally posted by SHOCKvalue View Post
                              No one associated with WSU in any official capacity is thinking anything about a P5 invite. Essentially no one in the fan base thinks otherwise either, but I'd imagine you could find a tiny sliver of uninformed, embarrassing, fringe WSU fans somewhere who have that pipe dream. We all have our special idiots.

                              The problem is, unfortunately, the MVC as a whole is not committed to athletic excellence. I'm not even sure they are committed to maintaining status quo, to be perfectly honest. The point of WSU bringing back football is not so that we can become the NDSU of FCS or the Boise or Houston of G5 FBS, it is simply so that we can perhaps grab a lifeline to get out of the sinking ship that is the MVC, before the vacuum of it going under takes WSU with it. That's it, and you can find quotes from our University President saying just that in a more diplomatic fashion.

                              Additionally, WSU is a bad fit quantitatively in the MVC:

                              *Even though we don't have a football component currently, our athletic budget is the largest in the MVC. If we added football and funded it at the average rate of MWC/AAC schools, the margin would become proportionally quite large.

                              *Our MBB budget is roughly twice as large as MVC number two, and close to three times the size of MVC average.

                              *Our endowment fund is again a couple of times larger than MVC number two, and multiples larger than MVC average. (In the context of the MVC publics - apples and oranges to compare endowments of public and private schools obviously.)

                              *Our research revenues are literally exponentially larger than most of the rest of the conference. I haven't looked it up in a while, but last I saw MVC number two in this regard was a long, long ways down from WSU.

                              *WSU is also in a level of Carnegie Classification that only ISUr shares in the MVC. What this means if you've never heard of the above is that WSU and ISUr are considered research universities, with the rest of the conference being more like large liberal arts colleges.

                              None of this is to take a crap on any one MVC school necessarily, especially UNI which seems to consistently do the most with what is provided. The point is simply that WSU's house is arguable and very possibly the largest and most valuable in a declining neighborhood, and we just want to move to a neighborhood where we can be the average (or even below average) home comparatively. If we make this move we'd hopefully also be moving ourselves out of a flood plain.

                              Ultimately, WSU might just be stuck in the MVC due to football and geography issues, but I'd bet good money this sorry conference is going to be on the wrong side of the demarcation line when the big shake-up happens, whereas conferences like the MWC, AAC, BE, and A10 might very well be safe.
                              Thank you Shockvalue! This is by far and away the most rational and realistic view of why WSU is looking to make the move. It goes beyond the claim of the MVC office "rigging" games against you and speaks to facts and numbers - right down my alley.

                              The MVC is great and all. However, if certain schools don't make a commitment soon, the reality after WSU's exit may not be pretty.

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Re: MVCF tells WSU to Piss Off

                                Thank you for the great, honest, and rational explanation Shockvalue.

                                I get why WSU would want to take a step up to the AAC/MWC or even C-USA if offered an opportunity. From an educational peer standpoint, you are correct in those probably being similar. From an athletic standpoint, playing conference basketball games vs UConn, Memphis, Cinci, etc...(unless they bolt for P5/Big East type conference) would be attractive, and makes sense.

                                From UNI's perspective, I think what we bring to the table is more or less consistency and stability within the MVC. Right now, you really aren't hearing anything regarding sports being cut, multimillion dollar athletic dept cuts, etc...like you are hearing from SIU/ILSU/MoState. We try to not get too big for our britches, I guess is what I'm saying. We know that there will always be some financial inequalities between us and the two other state schools as well as with Wichita. But we don't make excuses for it on the field of play. I think at this point in time, consistency trumps whatever is taking place in the state of Illinois and with Missouri State and Indiana State appropriations. I don't get hung up on endowment numbers. While they are nice to have, you need to have money coming in consistently to run operations and do capital funding. Loyola supposedly has a large endowment. Cool...are they the front runners in the conference? UNI needs to consistently increase their donation levels AND endowment, but endowment levels can decrease substantially depending on the market.

                                One final thing...is having a conference with similar peer institutions academically important? Honest question. Do most conferences get together to share their research exclusively with each other or does that take place more regionally or nationally when research groups combine together? At UNI, we obviously aren't a research institution. We are an educational institution. Educating Iowans most importantly is the goal. No need to have TA's or GA's teach classes while the professor does research in the lab. That's been UNI's philosophy but I honestly don't know if having similarly minded peer institutions in the conference helps a school or not. I'd like to hear some insight on this from those more educated than myself.
                                The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X