I didn't say that we couldn't play with the big boys, or that they were going to beat us up and pull our jock straps over our heads. All I was trying to say was that FSU/LSU/Miami are going to play us all out, and that these guys are gonna beat us like red-headed stepchildren and there could be a physical toll on us. What I find interesting is that no one is commenting on the close margin in the Gateway and in FCS ball. How many seasons has the conference championship been decided from a three-way tie? Is a paycheck worth the loss that might keep us from winning the Gateway or cost us a spot in the playoffs due to overall record?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
UNI Payday Game @ LSU/FSU/Miami?
Collapse
X
-
These games are a terrible idea. Lets stop having the football team prop up the rest of the athletic department! I'm sorry, but this is ridiculous. Travelling to LSU, Miami, FSU, etc. is a GUARANTEED, CERTIFIABLE loss; no matter how good we are in that particular year. For the money, I'd stay with the games with Iowa and ISU each/every other year if we must, and consider taking a year off every 3-5 from a FBS game. When we are playing a 3-4 loss and you're done schedule each year, it'd sure be nice to cut one of those losses out of the top... Let's play Drake every year...or bring in a decent FCS team to play in the Dome. An extra home game brings in money too; not as much as a LSU payday, but let's be realistic...
Comment
-
Now you're getting somewhere. This is a big conflict a lot of people have. Whats more important? A win or a big payout?Originally posted by DomeRanger Posse View PostWhat I find interesting is that no one is commenting on the close margin in the Gateway and in FCS ball. How many seasons has the conference championship been decided from a three-way tie? Is a paycheck worth the loss that might keep us from winning the Gateway or cost us a spot in the playoffs due to overall record?
The bottom line here is THE BOTTOM LINE. This is, was, and always will be money. College football funds athletic departments nationwide. Including our own with big payout games. Our football team and athletic department absolutely needs this payout game to pay the bills. Its the same reason there are 30 insignificant bowl games and 12 game seasons now. UNI is at a disadvantage compared to some of other schools it plays in the Valley like Creighton, Wichita, Bradley, Evansville, because they don't have football. Plus, UNI doesn't have the grad-school base and/or big money donors like some of the other places.
Wins are nice, but if you can't afford to field a team then you won't be watching those fun Panther victories year in and year out. A big money game will always be a part of UNI's scheduling because it has to be.
Plus, the team has every opportunity to win games despite the guaranteed loss payday. They just didn't take advantage of it: see North Dakota and WIU.Last edited by Matt Trump; 08-29-2007, 03:08 PM.
Comment
-
Id rather play a team from the midwest (Nebraska, Minnesota, etc) but if that isnt a possibility then we really have no other choice. We need the money game. We'd get killed but it could be a good experience if we could keep it within 40 or so. I dont know.Sincerely,
The Future AD of the University of Northern Iowa
Comment
-
In the past the Panthers have played out of state BCS teams like Minnesota, Pittsburgh, K-State, Oklahoma State, and various MAC teams. Quite frankly, we've worn out our welcome in the general Midwest. The arguement that we need a 6th home game doesn't work because no one's beating the door down to play us in the Dome.
LSU isn't stupid. Why not play a well-coached team that you should defeat? They played ASU and ASU defeated UNI. To LSU, UNI looks like a similar program. Why not play us instead of a Buffalo or a BCS bottom feeder? I'd prefer a closer game to Iowa, but why not go national? Farley needs to trust himself and his team. One of these games every 2-3 years will only be a plus. Besides it didn't matter if we lost to ISU last year, defeat WIU and UNI would have been in the playoffs.
Comment
-
It appears Miami (FL) and LSU aren't legitimate possibilities.
Did a quick check of future schedules (novel idea, I know). LSU, Miami, Nebraska, ISU & Minnesota all have 12 games scheduled already (Gophs list "MAC Opponent" as their 12th) .. unless things have changed, which, admittedly, they sometimes do. However, FSU & Iowa do not.
Two places I saw listing 12 games for LSU however another site listed a game against North Texas and not La Tech and another site listed a reverse. So who knows?
LSU Schedule (12 Games Already):
8-30 North Texas
9-6 Troy
9-13 Louisiana Tech
9-20 @ Auburn
9-27 Mississippi State
10-11 @ Florida
10-18 @ South Carolina
10-25 Georgia
11-1 Tulane
11-15 Alabama
11-22 Mississippi
11-29 @ Arkansas
Miami (FL) Schedule (12 Games Already):
9-6 @ Florida
9-20 @ Texas A&M
TBA North Texas
TBA UCF
+ 8-Game ACC
Florida St Schedule (11 Games):
Florida
Colorado
Clemson
BC
VaTech
Wake
Miami (FL)
NC St
Ga Tech
Maryland
If you can get $350-400K to play Iowa, I'd take that in a heartbeat over going to FSU for $500K. In fact, if I'm RH, I'm on the phone trying to book that deal ASAP. Simple fact is, it might be "fun" to play FSU but in-state exposure is crucial. We turned a lot of heads with our performance at Iowa a couple of years ago. I had plenty of Hawk fans tell me they knew who was the best QB on the field that day and he wasn't wearing black & gold. And we more than represented in other areas besides just at QB. A game against Iowa, while a likely loss, presents infinitely more positives, IMHO, than FSU (or anywhere, really).
Somebody correct me if I'm wrong but did YSU not get about $600K for PSU last year (there was a great article about it on our board last year -- something to the effect of FCS schools should be able to muscle for money)?? Can't we start negotiating for more?? If we've got to travel all the way down to FSU to take the "L"... work for some more dough.
Comment
-
Facts:Originally posted by Matt Trump View PostIowa and ISU aren't going to give us more money. Thats why we need to play a powerhouse because they can afford to hand over more dough.
In 2005 Iowa paid UNI $325,000 to play @ Kinnick
In 2006 Iowa paid Montana $650,000 to play @ Kinnick (and still cleared $1.75 million on the game)
WHAT'S WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE????
$500K from FSU is about the equivalent to 350K from Iowa/ISU, when you factor in all the travel costs -- perhaps a bit more. Not to mention the "opportunity costs" of not being able to showcase your program in front of a statewide audience -- that is huge.
I think I'm also speaking to a larger issue here -- essentially this comes down to a "sales process" that you can translate to any business. I've worked with bosses that just want to see money of every kind come through the door and will bend over to make it happen. Then there are those that stand behind their product and hold true to the value of it and won't sacrifice money to get the deal done. Its all about positioning. The simple fact is that, especially in Iowa's case, they CAN pay us more money and we should go after it and not just feel, "oh lucky us, we were fortunate enough just to get it done." The evidence is RIGHT THERE -- there is a precedent!!! We need to play up the advantages that we do hold (mentioned by others earlier). Heck, on inflation alone we should get a lot more next year in a than previous years.
I know there are a lot more factors and I'm oversimplfying this process a bit (as a lot has to do with attendance and travel $$, etc) but it just seems odd to me that we can't command what the YSU's and Montana's of the world are getting. You could probably argue that we are a step behind the latter but on par with the former.Last edited by UNI MadCat; 08-30-2007, 09:27 AM.
Comment
-
I think Iowa needed to fill the date....so I'm completely guessing but, I bet Montana had to buy someone out on changing their schedule and Iowa to get the game helped.
I wonder if Iowa, ISU and UNI all be Board of Regents schools has any determination on how much they pay us?"We're not an ordinary school," said Fort. "We have tradition. We have a good team year after year. We rebuild, and it doesn't matter who we have coming back."
dti
Comment
-
In one way, I tend to agree with that, especially since this year's game might be ugly for ISU. But, I'd also think that Chezik/Pollard feel their team will be improving in the future, and a loss would be less likely for them after this year. The good attendance for a game with UNI would be hard to turn down if they feel they'll be improving to the point where a loss is unlikely.Originally posted by Khan4Cats View PostWe have Iowa State, but who's to say Chezik won't want to get away from that series after we smack him down this year.UNI isn't exactly splitting atoms in terms of academics. -run&blade
Comment
-
But, Iowa also needed to fill a date on short notice when they scheduled UNI.Originally posted by Chitown Panther View PostI think Iowa needed to fill the date....so I'm completely guessing but, I bet Montana had to buy someone out on changing their schedule and Iowa to get the game helped.
The thing with the UI and ISU payouts being lower than for other PCS teams might have something to do with lower travel costs for UNI getting to IC/Ames, and the fact that the game is great in-state exposure for UNI. UNI benefits in ways other than $$.UNI isn't exactly splitting atoms in terms of academics. -run&blade
Comment
-
I think you are right. Yes Montana got $600K but had to travel from Montana. Again I don't know what the travel costs are but I wonder how much they took home. AppSt is only getting $400K to go to Michigan so the $350K from ISU looks pretty good there too. YSU is going to make a killing on the $600K with a bus trip to tOSU, but again it is tOSU and not Iowa or Iowa State. OSU has $ to burn. See the March 5th Sports Illustrated for details on their athletic department. Heck their pistol team (yes at tOSU this is a varsity sport) gets to charter flights to competitions.Originally posted by TH1974 View PostBut, Iowa also needed to fill a date on short notice when they scheduled UNI.
The thing with the UI and ISU payouts being lower than for other PCS teams might have something to do with lower travel costs for UNI getting to IC/Ames, and the fact that the game is great in-state exposure for UNI. UNI benefits in ways other than $$.
Back to the main topic. Madcat, I never said this was a done deal, just that they were games that UNI had discussions about. I just wondered what people thought about the opportunity to play outside of the region for a FBS game. Something that hasn't happened since we went to Oklahoma St years ago (that is if you could OSU outside our region).
Even if we don't make as much money as we would with a more local team, I think the exposure for the team would be a great learning experience. Does a big loss to Miami hurt us more than a big loss at Iowa? If UNI is going to lose a big time game does one of these hurt our reputation more than the other?If computers ruled college basketball the way they do football, we'd have skipped all this March Madness monotony and just waited a month for the Kansas-Kentucky title game. And watched Northern Iowa play Cornell in the Poulan Weedeater Bowl. ~ Dwight Perry The Seattle Times
Comment
-
There would be a higher travel cost. To charter 70-90 people from Montana to Iowa, the cost of just that plane would be around $80,000-$100,000 and thats not counting what they had to spend on bringing their equitment. That is part of the reason they got a higher payout.Originally posted by TH1974 View PostBut, Iowa also needed to fill a date on short notice when they scheduled UNI.
The thing with the UI and ISU payouts being lower than for other PCS teams might have something to do with lower travel costs for UNI getting to IC/Ames, and the fact that the game is great in-state exposure for UNI. UNI benefits in ways other than $$."If you want to bet against this UNI football team, go ahead. But, I'd be very careful."
-UNI Head Football Coach Mark Farley
Comment




Comment