WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Doug McDermott To UNI

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

    Originally posted by 9YRPLAN View Post
    i was under the impression that Altman and Mac still dont get along for reasons that date back to benny's recruitment, yet dana offered him...
    They are not, to say the least, best of friends. So for Gonzo to imply that the only reason that Doug was recruited was because of his father's relationship with Jake is insane.

    Comment


    • #32
      Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

      Originally posted by 96' Alum View Post
      They are not, to say the least, best of friends. So for Gonzo to imply that the only reason that Doug was recruited was because of his father's relationship with Jake is insane.
      It's a good thing I didn't actually imply that then, I'd hate to be lumped into the insane group of PN posters like you.

      Reading comprehension is a lost art with your generation for the most part. Here's a starter lesson: Played a big part =/= the only reason.

      That's the only lesson you get for free, you'll have to pay me to educate you any further, and in your case you'd have to pay me a lot.
      GO PANTHERS!

      Comment


      • #33
        Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

        Comment


        • #34
          Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

          Originally posted by 96' Alum
          My generation???

          You make a huge argument that he was EVALUATED DIFFERENTLY because of who his father is.....

          Then in your own DOUCHEBAG way, you say that him getting a scholly with UNI was because his father, and Coach Jake are friends. But, in your brilliant estimation, that he is not the kind of player that UNI needs to sign.

          SO, in your OWN WORDS, forget the player rankings, because he was evaluated differently, and even though he held a full offer from Dana Altman, the only reason that he can play in the MVC is because his dad and Jake are best friends.


          So which is it douchebag??? Did you mean what you typed, or are you just that big of an ass that when called on what you write, you can't handle it, so you have to get all personal.

          YOU ARE A MORON!!!!

          And the kind of knowledge that you apparently have to offer, is on par with what my daughter gets in pre-kindergarten.
          I think you've made my point with this post better than anything I could say would.
          GO PANTHERS!

          Comment


          • #35
            Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

            Originally posted by GonzoCat View Post
            I think you've made my point with this post better than anything I could say would.

            By refuting what you wrote, I made your point. I can see that. I think the biggest I made point would be that you are an idiot, so then yes, I would agree that I made your point for you.

            As far as Doug McDermott (back to the original topic), let's let the young man actually get through his senior year, and see how much more of his game, and more importantly his body, develops before we place any expectations on him.

            Comment


            • #36
              Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

              Originally posted by 96' Alum View Post
              By refuting what you wrote, I made your point. I can see that. I think the biggest I made point would be that you are an idiot, so then yes, I would agree that I made your point for you.
              In order to refute what I wrote you would have to first be able to comprehend it, something you've clearly demonstrated you cannot do.

              You have the reading comprehension skills of a third grader. You have the emotional disposition of a kindergartner. It cheapens my UNI education if you are really an alum.
              GO PANTHERS!

              Comment


              • #37
                Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                Originally posted by GonzoCat View Post
                In order to refute what I wrote you would have to first be able to comprehend it, something you've clearly demonstrated you cannot do.

                You have the reading comprehension skills of a third grader. You have the emotional disposition of a kindergartner. It cheapens my UNI education if you are really an alum.
                As you said in another thread about NDSU fans, Gonzo -- Don't feed the troll. I don't think this one has made a single worthwhile post on here yet. If you don't talk to it, maybe it will go away.
                It's my kind of team, Charlie. My kind of team!

                Comment


                • #38
                  Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                  96' Alum.................I think I would keep any comments about being an idiot to myself.
                  Lettin' the cat outta the bag is a whole lot easier'n puttin' it back.

                  Before you wonder "Am I doing things right," ask "Am I doing the right things?"

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                    Don't get in the middle of this old man, internet tough guy contests can get pretty rough.

                    How you doing oldcat, long time no see. Maybe I'll try to stop by your car on Saturday, you still in the same spot?
                    Last edited by Panthers to the Bone; 10-14-2009, 06:27 PM.
                    GO PANTHERS!

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                      OK, I posted something this weekend on this thread, and my wireless internet connection was lost as I was trying to post it. It was a couple paragraphs long, and I hate when that happens, but I digress.

                      Some are questioning Doug's recruitment, and others have been questioning the players that will take over starting roles when Koch/Eglseder/Rodenberg graduate. A couple things to think about. In the past, we have wondered who will replace Gruber/Schneiderman...and the along came Stout and Coleman. Then, we wondered who would replace Stout and Coleman...and along came Eglseder and Koch...and now we ask the same question. There will be guys stepping up to fill the roles of Eglseder and Koch. Will UNI fill Jordan's shoes with a 7'0"-er? No. He's the first in UNI history, and it will take some time before someone else comes through to become the 2nd in UNI history. It's really difficult to find a guy like Adam to replace his height and athleticism. There really isn't a player in UNI's history who has had both and been successful...it will be difficult to replace his play at a high level too. You have to look at Big 10/12 rosters/recruits to be able to replace these two. However, UNI has done a solid job of identifying it's needs and has turned out student-athletes that will fill roles that do a more than adequate job of being successful.

                      We don't know anything about Austin Pehl and Jake Koch. They both redshirted last year, and besides the fact that Pehl looked light years better in one exhibition game than he did in high school, we can only hope his development has continued at that same pace. Austin is a rare breed. He possesses more height in the post than Adam, but is probably similar athletically. Where Austin's game diverts from Adam is that there is no outside or dribble penetration game with Austin. To have a 6'10" post player who is relatively strong and athletic, is a good thing. Jake has a better outside game than Lucas or Austin, coming in from HS. I can only imagine that this has improved. He's about the same height as Adam (a year ago, I would have said Adam was taller, but I'm not sure anymore). He's listed at 6'9", so to have a tall forward spreading defenses to the perimeter will make things easier for Austin and Lucas the following year.

                      This leads me to the other scholarship players (the 2010 recruits). Doug McDermott, by all resources I have privy to is the highest rated incoming freshman recruit nationally in UNI history. EVER. He's rated by Bob Gibbons (long time national recruiting evaluator) as the #130 recruit nationally. Another recruiting website (again long time recruiting site) Hoop Scoop has reportedly listed Doug b/t 100-200 nationally. UNI's highest rated freshman recruit has been Ben Jacobson, Adam Koch, or Brooks McKowen (depending on which sites you look at)...and none were rated in the top 250 nationally We've had transfers who have been highly rated (Carlton, Jon Godfread, Sedrick Robinson, etc...), but none were freshmen recruits. Doug has proven his play in the AAU circuit. He averaged over 23 points per game in a big time AAU tournament this summer against some of the top competition. He shot 71% from the field last year (not from 2, but 2's and 3's, which he has a strong capability to do). Doug also did this against 4A competition (and also national competition at the AAU level). He's not physically imposing, and like most 6'7"+ high school seniors, he really needs to get stronger. That will come, but his knack for the basketball coming off the rim, and his outside shot to spread defenses is what has made UNI basketball what it is to date. Schneids, Stout, Koch, etc...have all been bigs (recently) who have been able to do both rebound and score from the perimeter...and Doug is probably a better rebounder than one or two of them too at this point. His recruitment (especially as the summer AAU circuit went on) became, and was a no brainer. Once again, Jake and the staff did a great job of identifying talent at an early stage in the recruiting process and was able to snag what might be the top ranked recruit in the Valley.

                      Did Mac playing at UNI help? Yeah. Did Jake being BFF's with Mac help? Sure. Did it seal the deal...no way. Doug was able to see himself playing basketball within a system that his Dad helped mold, which I think makes great sense for UNI basketball now and into the future. Doug is a smart kid and his growth spurt in the last year of about 4-5 inches hopefully won't stop. I think he could top out with another inch or two to become 6'8"/6'9", and how impressive would it be for UNI to say they could have a frontline group of 6'10" (Pehl), 6'9" (Koch), 6'8" (McDermott), 6'8" (Buss), 6'7" (Lange), 6'6" (Rank). I'd like to see UNI land the 6'8" Tuttle kid from West Fork, which would be another nice addition in a couple years, but I digress.

                      The moral of the story is that in the past UNI has lost guys in the post to graduation, and the following year, there is some nice talent to step into place. I don't see a reason why this won't continue to happen with the current regime in place.
                      The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                        PTTB - again, a well constructed, rational post. Why is it here with the rest of our posts?

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                          Originally posted by Panthers to the Bone View Post
                          OK, I posted something this weekend on this thread, and my wireless internet connection was lost as I was trying to post it. It was a couple paragraphs long, and I hate when that happens, but I digress.
                          That kind of thing has happened to me a couple times. I've avoided it a few times since then by pasting my lengthy ramblings into WordPad or something similar as I type them so I don't lose it if it crashes.
                          It's my kind of team, Charlie. My kind of team!

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                            Well said PTTB.
                            Raised a Hawkeye, Panther by choice.






                            Comment


                            • #44
                              Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                              great insight as always.

                              Comment


                              • #45
                                Re: Doug McDermott To UNI

                                Originally posted by GonzoCat View Post
                                Moon is overly critical, but you shouldn't pretend he was evaluated and recruited in the normal fashion either. He is a friend of the family and that played a big part in this scholly offer. I don't think he is up to par with most of the players we have recruited the past 3-4 years, but hopefully he can make a contribution to the program at some point. Personally I was hoping he would go to central florida or where ever. We are going to be weak in the post for years to come after this year and I don't think DM is the answer to that problem. If he proves me wrong I'll admit it.
                                I don't think the family connections had anything to do with the offer. They may have helped to land him, but we would have been crazy not to offer a kid with this much talent.

                                I also don't understand the not "up to par" statement. Is this your own personal evaluation after seeing him play or are you getting this from somewhere else? Everything that I've heard is that he should be a very good player. Rivals.com tends to agree and gave him a 3-star rating, which few other UNI commits have received (Sonnen, Moran, & Barz); neither Koch nor Eggs had a rating that high. The folks who get paid to make these types of evaluations think that he's not only "up to par" with our past recruits, but potentially better than most of them.

                                I'm not saying you are definitely wrong (nobody really knows at this point), but I would like to better understand your perspective to make sense of your evaluation.
                                TH1974: This guy was all-UNI, and wanted to show it by pretending to play a non-existant musical instrument in public.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X