WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #46
    Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

    Originally posted by panther-state View Post
    I think the big issue is that the moral integrity of UI athletics is already in question (for very good reason) and then they go out an give a scholarship to a guy who helped rob and beat-up a 71 year old man.

    It does look like a desperation move and I'm not saying that prisoners should not be given second chances but felons are stripped of many rights because of their choices and violent offenders, and I don't think its right that this kid is going to get a free college education just because he is good at basketball. I just think it promotes a backwards principle when people who have committed violent crimes are able to gain more privileges than normal college students just because they are athletically gifted. Honestly I don't think he has a right to play college athletics, and at the very least he should have to be a walk-on without the ability to earn a scholarship. Someone else could use that money.
    this/.01 ten characters

    Comment


    • #47
      Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

      Wierd, PantherHawk and 9 Year are trying to justify why it was okay the Hawks recruited this kid and of course why we are "haters" because we poke fun at it...
      Illinois State Fan at a St. Louis White Castle 3:45AM Saturday March 6th:

      "White Castle?" "more like Black Castle..."

      You stay classy Redbirds.

      Comment


      • #48
        Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

        I didn't realize Jevon Lyle was involved in the first ever fight between teammates.

        Iowa fans can't say a word about the Mayor anymore, none of his transfers were ever charged with a crime, let alone spent 47 months in prison. Apparently Fran is a desperate, desperate man. Taking a giant risk for a kid that was only offered by Nebraska and Iona...

        Comment


        • #49
          Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

          I just think it promotes a backwards principle when people who have committed violent crimes are able to gain more privileges than normal college students just because they are athletically gifted. <-------------This

          I teach students who have criminal records, have spent time in jail, lived in juvenile detention centers, you name it. If you have chose to make these kind of decisions in your life, you shouldn't receive all the privilages in the world just because you can "ball". I don't care whether Iowa really needs a PF or not...find someone else. If you want to give this guy a shot, that is totally fine. However, make him earn it.

          I too hope that he makes it at Iowa, has a good career, and finds a job after earning a college degree. That would be the perfect turnaround for this guy, but at the same time, he should have to prove it a little more than just showing up and playing well on the basketball court. He got in trouble AFTER this arrest, so obviously prison didn't do what it was supposed to.

          I know that every school has had players who are questionable, us included. However, I don't recall us having someone who spent time in prison for multiple felonies. I don't remember us having someone beat up a 71 year old man and leaving him tied up. I wouldn't want this guy on my team regardless of how good he is.

          My grandpa always told me that you can take the thug out of the hood, but you can't take the hood out of the thug. I would be a little worried if I were the Hawks. I could see this coming back to haunt them, not only in terms of basketball, but in terms of image. Imagine the parents of future recruits. Do you think the upper-class church going family is going to want to send their only son to play with this guy? I doubt it.

          Comment


          • #50
            Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

            Originally posted by UNI View Post
            I just think it promotes a backwards principle when people who have committed violent crimes are able to gain more privileges than normal college students just because they are athletically gifted. <-------------This

            I teach students who have criminal records, have spent time in jail, lived in juvenile detention centers, you name it. If you have chose to make these kind of decisions in your life, you shouldn't receive all the privilages in the world just because you can "ball". I don't care whether Iowa really needs a PF or not...find someone else. If you want to give this guy a shot, that is totally fine. However, make him earn it.

            I too hope that he makes it at Iowa, has a good career, and finds a job after earning a college degree. That would be the perfect turnaround for this guy, but at the same time, he should have to prove it a little more than just showing up and playing well on the basketball court. He got in trouble AFTER this arrest, so obviously prison didn't do what it was supposed to.

            I know that every school has had players who are questionable, us included. However, I don't recall us having someone who spent time in prison for multiple felonies. I don't remember us having someone beat up a 71 year old man and leaving him tied up. I wouldn't want this guy on my team regardless of how good he is.

            My grandpa always told me that you can take the thug out of the hood, but you can't take the hood out of the thug. I would be a little worried if I were the Hawks. I could see this coming back to haunt them, not only in terms of basketball, but in terms of image. Imagine the parents of future recruits. Do you think the upper-class church going family is going to want to send their only son to play with this guy? I doubt it.
            Great Post!

            Comment


            • #51
              Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

              Are people in this thread really saying that kids shouldn't get opportunities based on athletic ability alone? Its what the entire system is based on for the revenue sports. Even UNI has dozens if not hundreds who would not have been accepted if not for talent in a certain sport.

              I am skeptical of iowas decision but I also recognize that this guy served his time and in America that means that most of his rights are restored. If you want to argue that schools should take the moral high road and not give him a chance, I can live with that, but don't go and argue that it shouldn't happen in college sports.

              Comment


              • #52
                Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                Leaders are constantly sending messages with the decisions they make.

                There have been some really strange messages coming out of the UI athletic dept over the last few years.

                This one tells everyone that they have very low standards for the type of person they are bringing in to their athletic programs.

                Whether the guy is a bad person or not isn't really the point. He's a convicted felon who served hard time. He will forever be labeled as that. Fair or not, he will. Now Iowa has said "we'll take someone convicted of a violent crime if he can help us win."

                That's the message that others will hear.

                This is very dangerous for Iowa. If this kid makes a big mistake, which is not uncommon in the Iowa City environment based on prior history, this will be a huge embarrassment.
                Winning is more fun than losing.

                Comment


                • #53
                  Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                  Originally posted by 9YRPLAN View Post
                  Are people in this thread really saying that kids shouldn't get opportunities based on athletic ability alone? Its what the entire system is based on for the revenue sports. Even UNI has dozens if not hundreds who would not have been accepted if not for talent in a certain sport.
                  No we're saying that a guy who violently robs and assaults an elderly man should NOT get his college education paid for and have all of that forgotten and swept under the rug just because he's got some hops and a solid jumper. Start pointing out all of the violent offenders on UNI's rosters, much less the felons who roam our campus while also getting all of that tuition, housing, etc...paid for and I will be quiet. Thought so.

                  None of us have said that he shouldnt have the opportunity to play college basketball and get a college degree but giving him those opportunities for free?? Now thats asinine and an embarassment to the integrity of Iowa athletics. UI already has a lot of question marks next to that integrity and if this kid slips up at all it could be a disaster. I would be embarassed if this situation was turned around and he was coming here for free.

                  It's disappointing to see people defend his actions or the motivations behind this move for Iowa...if he were going to ISU or a Big 10 school what would you be thinking?.....Exactly.

                  Comment


                  • #54
                    Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                    Originally posted by panther-state View Post
                    I think the big issue is that the moral integrity of UI athletics is already in question (for very good reason) and then they go out an give a scholarship to a guy who helped rob and beat-up a 71 year old man.

                    It does look like a desperation move and I'm not saying that prisoners should not be given second chances but felons are stripped of many rights because of their choices and violent offenders, and I don't think its right that this kid is going to get a free college education just because he is good at basketball. I just think it promotes a backwards principle when people who have committed violent crimes are able to gain more privileges than normal college students just because they are athletically gifted. Honestly I don't think he has a right to play college athletics, and at the very least he should have to be a walk-on without the ability to earn a scholarship. Someone else could use that money.
                    Yes, exactly. Good post.
                    UNI FIGHT

                    Originally posted by 9YRPLAN
                    iowa sucks, fran sucks, their schedule sucks, iowa fans suck

                    Comment


                    • #55
                      Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                      Swept under the rug? He did four years in prison, and has been straight for an additional four years. In america, that means you can do just about everything a "regular" person would do. He can't vote, he can't carry a gun, so maybe you need to contact your local legislator and complain about his privately-funded scholarship. His story is out there for everyone to read

                      The scholarship offer was based on a judgment of his character. Its not my call, and I don't agree with it. But UNI has also failed miserably in that category over the past few years, but you don't see me accusing jake of wanting to win at all costs because he recruited guys that ended up committing armed robbery and dealing drugs.

                      And what's with your last point? I've said at least 5 times that I don't agree with it. Oh wait, you don't bother trying to understand anyone but yourself.

                      Comment


                      • #56
                        Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                        Originally posted by 9YRPLAN View Post
                        But UNI has also failed miserably in that category over the past few years, but you don't see me accusing jake of wanting to win at all costs because he recruited guys that ended up committing armed robbery and dealing drugs.
                        And what exactly became of that recruit? He was dropped in the blink of an eye and UNI wanted NOTHING to do with him.

                        There is zero correlation to that situation, and this Iowa situation.
                        UNI FIGHT

                        Originally posted by 9YRPLAN
                        iowa sucks, fran sucks, their schedule sucks, iowa fans suck

                        Comment


                        • #57
                          Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                          Originally posted by 9YRPLAN View Post
                          Are people in this thread really saying that kids shouldn't get opportunities based on athletic ability alone?
                          Yes.

                          Originally posted by 9YRPLAN View Post
                          Its what the entire system is based on for the revenue sports.
                          Not true. The NCAA is based on student athletes having a chance to get an education while participating in amateur level sports. These kids are supposed to be treated as students first and have to qualify for acceptance to the institution just like every other applicant. The college sporting world may have evolved into something like you are describing, which is sad, but it certainly isn't the basis for collegiate level athletics.

                          Originally posted by 9YRPLAN View Post
                          Even UNI has dozens if not hundreds who would not have been accepted if not for talent in a certain sports.
                          Also not true. The NCAA prohibits athletes from getting special treatment when it comes to admittance. This is why your constantly hear about athletes not academically qualifying and heading to a judo school with more lenient entrance requirements.
                          Originally posted by TH1974
                          This guy was all-UNI, and wanted to show it by pretending to play a non-existant musical instrument in public.

                          Comment


                          • #58
                            Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                            You are completely crazy if you think athletes are not afforded special opportunities because of athletic skills. The NCAA has basic guidelines for eligibility but the admittance guidelines are up the school. I've had brilliant friends get turned down by michigan or ucla but yet borderline but fully qualified student athletes have no problems getting in. It happens at UNI as well.

                            Comment


                            • #59
                              Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                              Originally posted by 06panther10 View Post
                              And what exactly became of that recruit? He was dropped in the blink of an eye and UNI wanted NOTHING to do with him.

                              There is zero correlation to that situation, and this Iowa situation.
                              I am talking about how coaches have to judge character. Some kids make mistakes, some are just bad eggs.

                              Comment


                              • #60
                                Re: Hawks pick up a 24 year old sophomore out of a prison

                                Originally posted by BCPanther View Post
                                I didn't realize Jevon Lyle was involved in the first ever fight between teammates.

                                Iowa fans can't say a word about the Mayor anymore, none of his transfers were ever charged with a crime, let alone spent 47 months in prison. Apparently Fran is a desperate, desperate man. Taking a giant risk for a kid that was only offered by Nebraska and Iona...
                                Royce White was charged with shoplifting and assault in one incident. Theft of a laptop from a dorm in another.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X