WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

    Originally posted by williebat View Post
    I wonder if we can get aj over all big 10 teAms and all big 12 teams. Except Kansas. Worried about acc. Hope he signs with us this summer
    I would only be concerned about maybe 5-6 schools. Kansas, Duke, UNC, Kentucky, maybe Michigan State, maybe Indiana.

    AJ doesn't fit Kentucky's profile.

    Indiana is in a new situation with Archie Miller. Given Archie's recruiting ties to Virginia, Chicago, Detroit and Ohio I don't see him going after AJ. Dayton's roster last. There was just three players on Dayton's roster not from those areas last year - one from Greece. I guess technically went to HS in Milwaukee - he is the brother of the "Greek Freak". One was from the Bronx and the other was Baltimore

    Michigan State could be a bit of a sleeper, but I'm not sure I see him there. They need PG depth. They have 3 on the roster but 1 is a walk on. By 2018 it's going to be a Sr and a So and that's it. There is a VC for them in 2018 though with Foster Loyer. However, he is listed at 6' 155lbs and is just a 3*. His offers, other than Michigan State were Davidson, DePaul, Oakland, St Louis and Toledo. He committed in November, so it's possible his recruiting page wasn't updated at that point as there was "no reason too". I've seen that happen. AJ is actually ranked higher in than Foster across the board.

    Duke is in on Tyus Jones's younger brother but he seems to fit what Coach K does. I don't see AJ garnering Duke interest though without one or two others passing on them. They are still after 5* Trenton Duval in this years class, who is the #1 PG in the country. In 2018 it's Tre Jones (5*/#4 PG in the country) and Darius Garland (5*/#3 PG in the country).

    UNC signed a 5* (#4 PG in the country) in this years class and has 2 verbals for next years class. Granted those verbals look to be about equal to AJ. One is a 4* and the other is a 3*. We all know Roy enjoys him some under recruited Iowa kids.

    Kasnas would be the hardest one to pass up for AJ, and is the only one I'm actually concerned about. Having said that, they have 5 known, and active, offers to 2018 PGs. Two of those are in the top 3 in the country for PGs. The others are 4* kids but aren't "ranked". In terms of what I can find, AJ isn't far behind those players.

    AJ is currently a high 3*, and would be a 4-5* across the board, recruit if ONE of the major schools offered him. However, they aren't as most just assume he's ending up here. He's a 4* composite on 247. Currently in the top 100 players overall in the country. Top 20 PG in the country in 2018.

    As has been mentioned here, if his dad was an accountant at Mudd the chances that AJ has offers from Iowa, Iowa State, Illinois, Kansas State, Butler, and about a dozen others is about 99%. However, his father is a long time UNI assistant who is well known in the coaching world (along with Jake) for their love of UNI.

    These coaches know AJ grew up in the McLeod center. Outside of the true blue bloods, very few schools feel there isn't much reason to waste recruiting time/money on him. A few smaller programs took fliers early (UND and SDSU) to see if they could grab him before he got bigger. UNI uses that method all the time. I would doubt they've had any contact with him in a year.

    To some extent, even with the AAU circut, the major P5 schools won't offer a kid unless he's "worked his way up" the recruiting trail. Low major offers, mid major offers, high mid major/low high major offers, high major offers. The fact that Iowa State offered, and that didn't start the trickle effect of other offers from larger schools says 1 of 2 things. Recruiting services are greatly overvaluing AJ OR schools don't want to "waste" time trying to get him. I would guess if he doesn't have a offer from a Duke, UNC, Wisconsin, Michigan State, Kansas, etc... by the end of the summer it isn't coming. I would guess that of the blue bloods the only ones actually worth being concerned about are Kansas, Duke and UNC. There might be a Creighton or Butler level offer but with the "dad" thing at UNI I think most places will just avoid it - except Greg asking Kyle to put his friend hat on.

    Comment


    • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

      Originally posted by claw View Post
      I would only be concerned about maybe 5-6 schools. Kansas, Duke, UNC, Kentucky, maybe Michigan State, maybe Indiana.

      AJ doesn't fit Kentucky's profile.

      Indiana is in a new situation with Archie Miller. Given Archie's recruiting ties to Virginia, Chicago, Detroit and Ohio I don't see him going after AJ. Dayton's roster last. There was just three players on Dayton's roster not from those areas last year - one from Greece. I guess technically went to HS in Milwaukee - he is the brother of the "Greek Freak". One was from the Bronx and the other was Baltimore

      Michigan State could be a bit of a sleeper, but I'm not sure I see him there. They need PG depth. They have 3 on the roster but 1 is a walk on. By 2018 it's going to be a Sr and a So and that's it. There is a VC for them in 2018 though with Foster Loyer. However, he is listed at 6' 155lbs and is just a 3*. His offers, other than Michigan State were Davidson, DePaul, Oakland, St Louis and Toledo. He committed in November, so it's possible his recruiting page wasn't updated at that point as there was "no reason too". I've seen that happen. AJ is actually ranked higher in than Foster across the board.

      Duke is in on Tyus Jones's younger brother but he seems to fit what Coach K does. I don't see AJ garnering Duke interest though without one or two others passing on them. They are still after 5* Trenton Duval in this years class, who is the #1 PG in the country. In 2018 it's Tre Jones (5*/#4 PG in the country) and Darius Garland (5*/#3 PG in the country).

      UNC signed a 5* (#4 PG in the country) in this years class and has 2 verbals for next years class. Granted those verbals look to be about equal to AJ. One is a 4* and the other is a 3*. We all know Roy enjoys him some under recruited Iowa kids.

      Kasnas would be the hardest one to pass up for AJ, and is the only one I'm actually concerned about. Having said that, they have 5 known, and active, offers to 2018 PGs. Two of those are in the top 3 in the country for PGs. The others are 4* kids but aren't "ranked". In terms of what I can find, AJ isn't far behind those players.

      AJ is currently a high 3*, and would be a 4-5* across the board, recruit if ONE of the major schools offered him. However, they aren't as most just assume he's ending up here. He's a 4* composite on 247. Currently in the top 100 players overall in the country. Top 20 PG in the country in 2018.

      As has been mentioned here, if his dad was an accountant at Mudd the chances that AJ has offers from Iowa, Iowa State, Illinois, Kansas State, Butler, and about a dozen others is about 99%. However, his father is a long time UNI assistant who is well known in the coaching world (along with Jake) for their love of UNI.

      These coaches know AJ grew up in the McLeod center. Outside of the true blue bloods, very few schools feel there isn't much reason to waste recruiting time/money on him. A few smaller programs took fliers early (UND and SDSU) to see if they could grab him before he got bigger. UNI uses that method all the time. I would doubt they've had any contact with him in a year.

      To some extent, even with the AAU circut, the major P5 schools won't offer a kid unless he's "worked his way up" the recruiting trail. Low major offers, mid major offers, high mid major/low high major offers, high major offers. The fact that Iowa State offered, and that didn't start the trickle effect of other offers from larger schools says 1 of 2 things. Recruiting services are greatly overvaluing AJ OR schools don't want to "waste" time trying to get him. I would guess if he doesn't have a offer from a Duke, UNC, Wisconsin, Michigan State, Kansas, etc... by the end of the summer it isn't coming. I would guess that of the blue bloods the only ones actually worth being concerned about are Kansas, Duke and UNC. There might be a Creighton or Butler level offer but with the "dad" thing at UNI I think most places will just avoid it - except Greg asking Kyle to put his friend hat on.
      The offer from ISU is very interesting. It gives him a chance to play close to home and in a major conference. They also get up and down the floor and shoot the 3. That style of play could be very appealing to a player like AJ who is good in the open court and a really good shooter. I haven't looked to see who else they have signed or what their PG situation is, but I wouldn't rule them out yet. The other piece of that is unknown is what AJ wants to do after basketball and his field of study and how that factors in to his decision.

      I could be wrong, but I don't expect to see an offer come from Creighton. I feel like the McDermotts likely don't want to face the backlash that would come with an offer or the situation it would put the Green family in after everything that happened with Doug.

      Comment


      • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

        Originally posted by hoopfan View Post
        The offer from ISU is very interesting. It gives him a chance to play close to home and in a major conference. They also get up and down the floor and shoot the 3. That style of play could be very appealing to a player like AJ who is good in the open court and a really good shooter. I haven't looked to see who else they have signed or what their PG situation is, but I wouldn't rule them out yet. The other piece of that is unknown is what AJ wants to do after basketball and his field of study and how that factors in to his decision.

        I could be wrong, but I don't expect to see an offer come from Creighton. I feel like the McDermotts likely don't want to face the backlash that would come with an offer or the situation it would put the Green family in after everything that happened with Doug.
        Iowa State has a 5 star kid coming in this year, #23 in the country, Lindell Wigginton.

        I'm with claw, I think the only way he doesn't come here is if a true blue blood comes along.

        Comment


        • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

          Iowa State signed 2 PGs in this year class and have a minimum of 9 open offers to PGs in the 2018 class. I'm not making that up. Iowa State has 23 known, valid, offers out for the 2018 class right now. I can find offers to Darius Garland, Elijah Weaver, Terrence Moss, Tyler Harris, Jamie Lewis, Jalen Carey, Ayo Dosunmu, Xavier Castaneda, AJ Green. There might be a couple more. They also have an existing offer to Terryonte Thomas in this years class yet. They have an open spot and he's their only existing offer.

          I would guess that given the size of the net that Prohm cast on PGs he isn't going to be able to make all of them feel "wanted". Maybe AJ becomes his target to focus on, but with 23 open scholarships, a minimum of 9 of them being to PGs, and at least 2 (if not 3) PGs in the class a head of him, It just seems like a crowded CF situation to try to recruit and sign into.

          Comment


          • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

            Originally posted by claw View Post
            Iowa State signed 2 PGs in this year class and have a minimum of 9 open offers to PGs in the 2018 class. I'm not making that up. Iowa State has 23 known, valid, offers out for the 2018 class right now. I can find offers to Darius Garland, Elijah Weaver, Terrence Moss, Tyler Harris, Jamie Lewis, Jalen Carey, Ayo Dosunmu, Xavier Castaneda, AJ Green. There might be a couple more. They also have an existing offer to Terryonte Thomas in this years class yet. They have an open spot and he's their only existing offer.

            I would guess that given the size of the net that Prohm cast on PGs he isn't going to be able to make all of them feel "wanted". Maybe AJ becomes his target to focus on, but with 23 open scholarships, a minimum of 9 of them being to PGs, and at least 2 (if not 3) PGs in the class a head of him, It just seems like a crowded CF situation to try to recruit and sign into.
            Because when you desperately need some bigs, what you should search for is more guards.

            Comment


            • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

              Originally posted by claw View Post
              I would only be concerned about maybe 5-6 schools. Kansas, Duke, UNC, Kentucky, maybe Michigan State, maybe Indiana.
              I throw out one other option which concerns me more than all those listed above... Stanford. While it would be great for AJ and family, it sucks for us. Stanford is not close to any of the programs above, but they do have the academics and brand to set him up for life. You just don't walk past an offer from them.

              Comment


              • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                Originally posted by sevelev711 View Post
                Because when you desperately need some bigs, what you should search for is more guards.
                From what I can find

                9 PG offers
                4 SG offers
                5 SF offers
                6 PF offers
                0 C offers

                None of them are taller than 6'8.

                Not that 6'7 or 6'8 guys can't be/aren't effective post players but Iowa State doesn't have anyone over 6'8 currently. It's like the C position no longer exists in Ames. It's either genius or terrible recruiting.

                Comment


                • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                  Originally posted by FOTY View Post
                  I throw out one other option which concerns me more than all those listed above... Stanford. While it would be great for AJ and family, it sucks for us. Stanford is not close to any of the programs above, but they do have the academics and brand to set him up for life. You just don't walk past an offer from them.
                  I agree. I guess I'm somewhat optimistic because they've watched him several times and there hasn't been an offer.

                  Comment


                  • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                    Originally posted by claw View Post
                    From what I can find

                    9 PG offers
                    4 SG offers
                    5 SF offers
                    6 PF offers
                    0 C offers

                    None of them are taller than 6'8.

                    Not that 6'7 or 6'8 guys can't be/aren't effective post players but Iowa State doesn't have anyone over 6'8 currently. It's like the C position no longer exists in Ames. It's either genius or terrible recruiting.
                    In the last 6 seasons (all of which resulted in an NCAA tourney appearance) ISU has never had a legit player over 6'9" and for the most part, 6'8" was the height of our 5 man. (Georges Niang and Royce White both 6'8") Jameel McKay was 6'9".
                    With ISU's style of play, they would rather have an athletic forward in the 6'8ish range that can shoot the 3 and rim run than a slow, big man. And if there are any really athletic 6'10"+ guys that can shoot the 3, they aren't coming to ISU.
                    And moving forward for the next couple seasons, their main big guy still looks to be 6'8" Young and 6'9" Lard.
                    ISU does a great job playing small ball and its worked well.

                    Comment


                    • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                      Originally posted by cydave View Post
                      In the last 6 seasons (all of which resulted in an NCAA tourney appearance) ISU has never had a legit player over 6'9" and for the most part, 6'8" was the height of our 5 man. (Georges Niang and Royce White both 6'8") Jameel McKay was 6'9".
                      With ISU's style of play, they would rather have an athletic forward in the 6'8ish range that can shoot the 3 and rim run than a slow, big man. And if there are any really athletic 6'10"+ guys that can shoot the 3, they aren't coming to ISU.
                      And moving forward for the next couple seasons, their main big guy still looks to be 6'8" Young and 6'9" Lard.
                      ISU does a great job playing small ball and its worked well.
                      Yes if your goal is to "make" the tournament. If you want to "win" the tournament you might have to think bigger??

                      Comment


                      • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                        Originally posted by BCPanther View Post
                        I agree. I guess I'm somewhat optimistic because they've watched him several times and there hasn't been an offer.
                        Stanford will have 5 PGs in roster in 2018 and only one will be an upperclassmen. They also have offers to 5 other PGs on the 2018 class, not includin AJ.

                        Comment


                        • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                          Originally posted by r54uni View Post
                          Yes if your goal is to "make" the tournament. If you want to "win" the tournament you might have to think bigger??
                          The goal for every team is to just "make" the tournament. Whatever happens in the tournament is a total crapshoot.
                          If you want to "win" the tournament, its better to be hot than have a guy over 6'10".

                          Comment


                          • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                            Originally posted by cydave View Post
                            The goal for every team is to just "make" the tournament. Whatever happens in the tournament is a total crapshoot.
                            If you want to "win" the tournament, its better to be hot than have a guy over 6'10".
                            I doubt that Kansas, Kentucky, UNC, Duke, etc. are happy to make the tournament. If you are ISU or an ISU fan and that is truly your belief then there in-lies a huge problem.

                            Comment


                            • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                              Originally posted by r54uni View Post
                              I doubt that Kansas, Kentucky, UNC, Duke, etc. are happy to make the tournament. If you are ISU or an ISU fan and that is truly your belief then there in-lies a huge problem.
                              There's maybe 10-15 teams in the nation that can truly have realistic goals of winning the title each year. For the rest, making the tournament is a great goal. Then once you make the Tourney and see your matchups, you can re-evaluate your goals.
                              For ISU next season, making the tourney would be a very nice achievement. 2 years ago the goal was Sweet 16 at worst.

                              Comment


                              • Re: Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                                We offered in state forward James Betz today

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X