WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

College Football Live 50 State Tour

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

    Originally posted by jegbomb52 View Post
    Depends on how it is worded. Is he probably the greatest football player from Iowa in the game of football, yes.

    Was he the greatest Iowa College player ever, not even close. Depends on the critera.
    Exactly right on both counts. He's nowhere close to the greatest Iowa college player ever, due to only playing one year.

    You could make a good case for Bryce Paup's inclusion in the list of choices. Keep in mind that it obviously doesn't have to be an Iowa native, just someone who played college football in the state.

    It's too bad people have short memories (me included). The Iowa teams from the 50s under Evy were probably the best ever to come from the state, especially considering the lack of other bowls so their competition was as good as it got for the time. But, the '58 team probably won't get too many votes due to lack of knowledge by most fans. Dwayne Crutchfield was Iowa State's entire offense for a couple of years on some decent teams (especially by Iowa State's standards), and he also played some decent ball in the NFL. Earl Bruce showed his offensive creativity by running Crutchfield every "effing" offensive play, and defenses still couldn't totally shut him down. He didn't even make the list of top 5 choices.
    Last edited by SteinPizza; 06-10-2009, 05:03 PM.

    Comment


    • #17
      Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

      Its hard to discount a heisman trophy by Kinnick, but I have a hard time awarding best player to someone that played 70 years ago. I think at least in the last 20 to 30 years, Troy Davis has been the best player. 2,000 yard seasons for two years in a row, and almost winning a Heisman for a terrible team is pretty impressive.
      UNI FIGHT

      Originally posted by 9YRPLAN
      iowa sucks, fran sucks, their schedule sucks, iowa fans suck

      Comment


      • #18
        Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

        Originally posted by 06panther10 View Post
        Its hard to discount a heisman trophy by Kinnick, but I have a hard time awarding best player to someone that played 70 years ago. I think at least in the last 20 to 30 years, Troy Davis has been the best player. 2,000 yard seasons for two years in a row, and almost winning a Heisman for a terrible team is pretty impressive.

        Why can't someone be the "best" simply because he played a long time ago?

        Comment


        • #19
          Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

          Originally posted by Newsbreaker View Post
          Why can't someone be the "best" simply because he played a long time ago?
          1) Because nobody has seen them play.

          2) Because the game is sooo much different now.
          UNI FIGHT

          Originally posted by 9YRPLAN
          iowa sucks, fran sucks, their schedule sucks, iowa fans suck

          Comment


          • #20
            Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

            Originally posted by 06panther10 View Post
            1) Because nobody has seen them play.

            2) Because the game is sooo much different now.

            I agree the first point makes it harder to quantify and compare (which is why these discussions can be fun), but the fact that the game has changed doesn't prevent an older player from being better. If anything, innovation and gadgetry in the game may make today's player appear comparatively better than they are.

            He didn't play College ball in Iowa, but a mention has to go to an Iowa native...Jay Berwanger. The first Heisman Trophy winner. He was crazy good.

            Comment


            • #21
              Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

              Originally posted by 06panther10 View Post
              I think at least in the last 20 to 30 years, Troy Davis has been the best player. 2,000 yard seasons for two years in a row, and almost winning a Heisman for a terrible team is pretty impressive.
              Of course Troy Davis was good, damn good in fact. However, he also had some nice sized holes to run through. I still lived in DSM, and saw him live more than a few times. ISU loved to run inside with him, and often he was untouched until 4-5 yards downfield. ISU may have had a bad team, but they had a damn good line to open holes for him. One thing about him, he really brought the wood to tacklers for a guy his size. However, I have hard time saying he was the best college player ever in Iowa. You also have to take NFL success somewhat into account, because it's the best barometer of his talent relative to other elite players.

              If you want to talk about a guy who played on some bad/mediocre teams but still stood out...Ladell Betts for Iowa. I don't remember him having the advantage of the same blocking as Troy Davis.

              Comment


              • #22
                Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                Ladell Betts...c'mon. There is no comparison with Troy Davis and Ladell Betts. Iowa State's O lines from their teams with 2 wins were not much better, if at all, than the Iowa O lines that went to bowl games.

                If I remember correctly, Troy Davis has had a very successfull career playing in Canada, after his stint in the NFL.
                UNI FIGHT

                Originally posted by 9YRPLAN
                iowa sucks, fran sucks, their schedule sucks, iowa fans suck

                Comment


                • #23
                  Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                  Betts didn't have a good O-Line or go to a bowl game until his Sr year.

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                    Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
                    Of course Troy Davis was good, damn good in fact. However, he also had some nice sized holes to run through. I still lived in DSM, and saw him live more than a few times. ISU loved to run inside with him, and often he was untouched until 4-5 yards downfield. ISU may have had a bad team, but they had a damn good line to open holes for him. One thing about him, he really brought the wood to tacklers for a guy his size. However, I have hard time saying he was the best college player ever in Iowa. You also have to take NFL success somewhat into account, because it's the best barometer of his talent relative to other elite players.

                    If you want to talk about a guy who played on some bad/mediocre teams but still stood out...Ladell Betts for Iowa. I don't remember him having the advantage of the same blocking as Troy Davis.

                    I loved the running plays where the Oline would just drift left or drift right....and Troy would find his own hole. Probably the closest type of play in football to a freelance offense in basketball.
                    "We're not an ordinary school," said Fort. "We have tradition. We have a good team year after year. We rebuild, and it doesn't matter who we have coming back."

                    dti

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                      Originally posted by Dutch View Post
                      Interesting to see the amount of love the '07 UNI team gets
                      Down to 9%. What the heck happened?
                      "And immediately, (P'Allen Stinnett's) Facebook status was spouting vulgarities towards the university."

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                        Originally posted by 06panther10 View Post
                        Ladell Betts...c'mon. There is no comparison with Troy Davis and Ladell Betts. Iowa State's O lines from their teams with 2 wins were not much better, if at all, than the Iowa O lines that went to bowl games.

                        If I remember correctly, Troy Davis has had a very successfull career playing in Canada, after his stint in the NFL.
                        There's no way the ISU lines were better than Iowa's bowl teams from the early '00s. That like comparing Wartburg and UNI. Troy Davis was a very good college player, better than Ladell Betts. I'm not saying he didn't deserve to be in the top 5 choices...I'm saying that Ladell Betts put up good numbers with lines that didn't open the holes for him that Davis had, particularly his first couple of years. Ladell Betts is still playing in the NFL, which gives you some insight into his ability compared to Davis

                        Watching Davis back then was fun, because he'd usually be untouched for 4-5 yards, and then get a chance to really smack a Safety coming up to tackle him. He didn't dance a lot, just put his head down and went. Best examples I can think of would be a small Shonn Greene, or a really poor man's version of Walter Payton.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                          Originally posted by CincyPanther88 View Post
                          Down to 9%. What the heck happened?
                          My guess is that someone posted a link to this poll a squawkeye board or something.

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                            Its a completely new poll is the problem....
                            "We're not an ordinary school," said Fort. "We have tradition. We have a good team year after year. We rebuild, and it doesn't matter who we have coming back."

                            dti

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                              If we're talking about best college player to ever play in the state of Iowa, I think a strong case should be made for Drake's Johnny Bright.

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Re: College Football Live 50 State Tour

                                Originally posted by Chitown Panther View Post
                                Its a completely new poll is the problem....
                                aha. good catch.

                                They changed it from having two '76 Iowa teams (which was stupid, not only b/c of the duplicity, but because of that teams losing record) to having the '85 Iowa team. And the '02 Iowa team (can't remember if that was on there before)

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X