WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

    This talk of DJ not making an NFL roster or even getting an invite to the combine is absolute hogwash.

    Every single reputable draft board has DJ listed as one of the top 15 running backs available and most list him in the top 10.

    Once his combine and pro-day numbers get released, these projections will only improve.
    Originally posted by TH1974
    This guy was all-UNI, and wanted to show it by pretending to play a non-existant musical instrument in public.

    Comment


    • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

      Originally posted by Purrrrrfect View Post
      Just watch. I'll put my whole salary on it.
      David Johnson will be a draft pick and on the active roster of an NFL football team week 1 of the 2015 season barring some preseason injury. I will place any amount of money I have on it.

      The fact that you think David isn't a legitimate draft prospect (im not talking free agent signing here) is crazy. Every board in the country has him listed on it. Once your drafted forget about it, you are making the roster. Front offices hate to lose money, and they hate to look stupid.
      Illinois State Fan at a St. Louis White Castle 3:45AM Saturday March 6th:

      "White Castle?" "more like Black Castle..."

      You stay classy Redbirds.

      Comment


      • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

        I read on 2015 senior bowl that he is/could be invited to THE Senior Bowl in Alabama....and Xavier.....usually if you get that invite , you WILL be on a roster the next season. DJ physically is the best looking running back in FCS by far , and as far as pass catching RB he probably is in the Top 3 or 4 in all of college football. But , as a pure line up and run the ball down your throat type of RB , he kind of runs timid for someone who is as physically gifted as this stallion of a player. Xavier W will be drafted higher in (my) opinion --- he is a guy who I believe could end up on the depth chart very quickly for some needy NFL squad. And quite honestly , I believe two or three more may get invited as undrafted free agents to some camps.....we'll see???But keep in mind that we still have plenty of football left and a whole lot can change in a short period of time...

        Comment


        • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

          Sorry, took me a couple days to cool off.

          I'm gonna look back but I dont think I ever said he wouldn't be playing on Sundays, I just said his draft stock is getting a hit and would likely IMO at the time of anger/disappointment, result in undrafted FA.

          He certainly has the talent level. And I honestly believe he will play on Sundays somewhere. A clear mind helps wonders.

          And Kyle and jegbomb, unfortunately I don't work for salary anymore, but at the time thats how much I would want to bet had I had the money! You get the jist. And with the first of many Purrrrrfect Panther babies on the way I'd have to donate the cute lil one to pay for the bet

          Comment


          • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

            Originally posted by jegbomb52 View Post
            David Johnson will be a draft pick and on the active roster of an NFL football team week 1 of the 2015 season barring some preseason injury. I will place any amount of money I have on it.

            The fact that you think David isn't a legitimate draft prospect (im not talking free agent signing here) is crazy. Every board in the country has him listed on it. Once your drafted forget about it, you are making the roster. Front offices hate to lose money, and they hate to look stupid.
            Players are drafted every year that never see an active roster. You might mean 1st or 2nd round picks, but often it is better than go undrafted than get picked in the 6th or 7th round.

            Ask Michael Sam how well getting drafted did for making a roster.
            Number of times on Sports Illustrated cover:
            Ben Jacobson coached teams = 2
            UNI teams coached by everyone ban thinks is better = 0

            Comment


            • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

              Originally posted by Purrrrrfect View Post
              I'm gonna look back but I dont think I ever said he wouldn't be playing on Sundays,
              Depends on what days they play in Canada. You said he'd be CFL at best. Sounds like you are rethinking that now, which is fine, a lot of people say things they don't really believe in anger.
              GO PANTHERS!

              Comment


              • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                Originally posted by catsize View Post
                Players are drafted every year that never see an active roster. You might mean 1st or 2nd round picks, but often it is better than go undrafted than get picked in the 6th or 7th round.

                Ask Michael Sam how well getting drafted did for making a roster.
                Completely true - there's examples every year of draft picks getting cut after camp. The Steelers cut a 5th round CB this year. Maurice Clarett from OSU got cut after getting picked in the 3rd round, Demetrius Underwood was cut by Minnesota, despite being a 1st round pick by the Vikings.

                Granted DJ doesn't have the issues of most of the guys I just listed (outside of the Steelers CB), but it does happen. Sometimes it's just better to cut your losses when you find out you missed on someone and not waste a roster spot, public perception be damned. Lower round rookies aren't going to be on guaranteed deals at that point in their careers, either, so money doesn't come into it.

                It's all a moot point, anyway. If anyone doesn't think NFL scouts will love this kid based on his measurables alone, you haven't watched many drafts. 6-2, 225 running backs who lift like a demon don't grow on trees - he'll find a spot.
                Give us a yell, HO! The purple and the gold
                Victory for U-N-I!

                Find out what the other team wants to do, then take it away from them.
                - George Halas

                Comment


                • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                  Originally posted by 95UNIGRAD View Post
                  It's all a moot point, anyway. If anyone doesn't think NFL scouts will love this kid based on his measurables alone, you haven't watched many drafts. 6-2, 225 running backs who lift like a demon don't grow on trees - he'll find a spot.
                  Let me start by saying I think DJ will make a team next year. That said, you and several others here are confusing measurables with NFL level playing ability. There are plenty of clown a** GMs and scouts who rely way too much on combine and pro day metrics, without actually giving any thought (or not having the ability to see it) to whether the guy can actually play. He may have good/great college stats, but it's a whole different thing to put up numbers against NFL caliber players. The Bears alone have had several front office people who get/got wooed by combine numbers and wasted draft picks on lackluster players. They have one sitting in the GM chair now, and time will tell whether his player approach pans out.

                  The above is nothing against DJ. Just don't be awed too much when your team drafts a guy who can do 8,000 bench reps, sets records in the vertical jump and short shuttle, has a world class 40 time, etc.

                  Comment


                  • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                    Originally posted by catsize View Post
                    Players are drafted every year that never see an active roster. You might mean 1st or 2nd round picks, but often it is better than go undrafted than get picked in the 6th or 7th round.

                    Ask Michael Sam how well getting drafted did for making a roster.
                    Michael Sam was gay, if he would have stayed in the closet he would have been a 3rd / 4th round pick and still on a roster. If you are a draft pick and don't make a roster, I don't care if you are 2nd or 7th round, you are a bust.

                    According to nfl.com, in the last ten years 77% of sixth and seventh round draft picks have started a game in the NFL. I know thats not a "lock" but please don't change the "exception" to the "rule" just to benefit your argument.

                    David is going to play, I mean play meaningful downs, in the NFL because of his ability to catch the football, and do it against BCS opponents. Even if those opponents are Iowa State
                    Illinois State Fan at a St. Louis White Castle 3:45AM Saturday March 6th:

                    "White Castle?" "more like Black Castle..."

                    You stay classy Redbirds.

                    Comment


                    • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                      Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
                      Let me start by saying I think DJ will make a team next year. That said, you and several others here are confusing measurables with NFL level playing ability. There are plenty of clown a** GMs and scouts who rely way too much on combine and pro day metrics, without actually giving any thought (or not having the ability to see it) to whether the guy can actually play. He may have good/great college stats, but it's a whole different thing to put up numbers against NFL caliber players. The Bears alone have had several front office people who get/got wooed by combine numbers and wasted draft picks on lackluster players. They have one sitting in the GM chair now, and time will tell whether his player approach pans out.

                      The above is nothing against DJ. Just don't be awed too much when your team drafts a guy who can do 8,000 bench reps, sets records in the vertical jump and short shuttle, has a world class 40 time, etc.
                      You just supported what I said.

                      That's not my entire point anyway; what I've basically said throughout the thread is that even if his numbers are down this year due to poor game planning by the coaching staff, he's still got the measurables to catch attention. He clearly isn't a "measurables only" kind of guy, or he wouldn't be on draft lists.
                      Give us a yell, HO! The purple and the gold
                      Victory for U-N-I!

                      Find out what the other team wants to do, then take it away from them.
                      - George Halas

                      Comment


                      • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                        Originally posted by 95UNIGRAD View Post
                        You just supported what I said.

                        That's not my entire point anyway; what I've basically said throughout the thread is that even if his numbers are down this year due to poor game planning by the coaching staff, he's still got the measurables to catch attention. He clearly isn't a "measurables only" kind of guy, or he wouldn't be on draft lists.
                        No, he's had production, particularly as a pass catcher. My point is there are idiots in that field who will let the metrics and pro day stats dictate where he is drafted, rather than production on the field. As a Bears fan, I get sick thinking of wasted draft picks who had great measurables. Those same guys are working at grocery stores or insurance companies after very short careers in the league, while other teams chose wisely and found actual talent.

                        One thing is true though...to play in the league, you HAVE to have speed and athletic ability, so it's a always a balancing act between paper speed and agility stats versus what they see on film. Particularly a small school or mid major prospect like DJ who played against inferior competition. Some of you may not like to read that, but it's the truth.

                        Comment


                        • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                          Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
                          No, he's had production, particularly as a pass catcher. My point is there are idiots in that field who will let the metrics and pro day stats dictate where he is drafted, rather than production on the field. As a Bears fan, I get sick thinking of wasted draft picks who had great measurables. Those same guys are working at grocery stores or insurance companies after very short careers in the league, while other teams chose wisely and found actual talent.

                          One thing is true though...to play in the league, you HAVE to have speed and athletic ability, so it's a always a balancing act between paper speed and agility stats versus what they see on film. Particularly a small school or mid major prospect like DJ who played against inferior competition. Some of you may not like to read that, but it's the truth.
                          As a fellow Bears fan, I still shudder when I hear the name Jarron Gilbert. Or as most Bears fans know him, "the guy who could jump out of a swimming pool".
                          Give us a yell, HO! The purple and the gold
                          Victory for U-N-I!

                          Find out what the other team wants to do, then take it away from them.
                          - George Halas

                          Comment


                          • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                            Originally posted by 95UNIGRAD View Post
                            As a fellow Bears fan, I still shudder when I hear the name Jarron Gilbert. Or as most Bears fans know him, "the guy who could jump out of a swimming pool".
                            Dan Bauzien too, from Boise St. I think. Bauzein was a second round draft choice, and was an absolute bust. Jarron Gilbert was as well, and that's just the start of the list. Both guys, and several others, were drafted where they were purely due to combine and pro day workouts, not actual playing ability at the NFL level. To quote an old phrase, they looked like Tarzan, but played like Jane.

                            Comment


                            • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                              Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
                              Dan Bauzien too, from Boise St. I think. Bauzein was a second round draft choice, and was an absolute bust. Jarron Gilbert was as well, and that's just the start of the list. Both guys, and several others, were drafted where they were purely due to combine and pro day workouts, not actual playing ability at the NFL level. To quote an old phrase, they looked like Tarzan, but played like Jane.
                              Bazuin was from Western Michigan. You're probably thinking of another soon-to-be-bust from the Bears' drafts, Shea Mclellin.

                              To be fair, though, those guys weren't drafted purely on how they looked at the combine. Sure it helped that they looked like workout warriors, but Gilbert was his conference's defensive player of the year as a senior. Bazuin put up 26.5 sacks in his final two years of college and led the nation in tackles for loss as a junior - he was an absolute beast, albeit at a MAC level. Michael Sam was co-defensive player of the year in a loaded SEC, then was unimpressive at the combine, foreshadowing his inability to play at an NFL level (now out of a job after 2 teams since being drafted in May).

                              Just goes to show that we can't make definitive statements about the importance of the combine or importance of a good college career. It's all a crapshoot, and then throw personalities and coachability into it since they are people, too, and it's evident that a lot of it is luck once you get past the top picks in the 1st rd.
                              Give us a yell, HO! The purple and the gold
                              Victory for U-N-I!

                              Find out what the other team wants to do, then take it away from them.
                              - George Halas

                              Comment


                              • Re: The South Dakota State @ Northern Iowa Game Thread

                                Michael Sam was also too small to play D-End and too slow to be a rush linebacker. Classic tweaner. That doesn't work in the NFL...

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X