WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Official 'Just the Fact' Playoff Outlook

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    What do people think about the YSU and Ill st. game this weekend. Who winning would favor UNI more? Personally I think that we want Ill St. to win. Then, when we play them, we would have a chance to beat a top 2 ranked team.

    Comment


    • #17
      Originally posted by pantherclaw View Post
      I agree, that's one of the better points. And i think the Gateway has a big opportunity if UNI, ILS, and SIU go undefeated(minus their game against UNI) that would put SIU at 8-3, and ILS at 9-2, and us at 9-2 with us as the auto-bid. SIU would have a huge plus, beating Indiana, and well ILS would just kick butt and the close win over K-State. I think that's what its gonna be gateway wise.

      Im just gonna put this out there, only way we make the playoffs is win out, or with only one more loss to ILS. IMO
      Understand, no non-scholly/mid-major has EVER made the I-AA playoff field. In the past, it has been considered next-to-impossible to do so, to the point that the Pioneer League and another have put together a contest for their champions to meet in a "bowl" game, so there's some post-season birth to shoot for.

      With that in mind, there's no reason for them NOT to schedule a game the weekend of Round 1. Every expectation is that there's no reason not to, and it means a week of football once a good portion of the nation has gone into shut down mode.

      We won't get 4 teams in guys, it's just not going to happen. Personally, I don't think 3 is likely either. Again, that would give us 1/4 of the at-large teams, leaving only 6 slots for seven other leagues to split. Unlikely.

      Comment


      • #18
        News-

        I'm not 100% sure your statement that no non-scholly has gotten a bid. Maybe someone could help me out, but I was thinking that a non-scholy from out East got in....or were they a 'need-based equivalency' type school?
        The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

        Comment


        • #19
          Originally posted by dometop View Post
          What do people think about the YSU and Ill st. game this weekend. Who winning would favor UNI more? Personally I think that we want Ill St. to win. Then, when we play them, we would have a chance to beat a top 2 ranked team.

          We want ISU, IMHO. With a bad loss, we want a win against ISU to mean as much as possible, and that's only going to happen if they keep winning.

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by Panthers to the Bone View Post
            News-

            I'm not 100% sure your statement that no non-scholly has gotten a bid. Maybe someone could help me out, but I was thinking that a non-scholy from out East got in....or were they a 'need-based equivalency' type school?
            About 1/3 down the linked story:

            -The 23 teams from the three "I-AA mid-major" conferences (MAAC, NEC, Pioneer) are technically playoff eligible, though no team from any of those non-scholarship leagues has ever been chosen for the field.
            http://www.sportsnetwork.com/default...ong_110903.htm

            Comment


            • #21
              Good find. I could have sworn that just a couple years ago one got in, but I guess I was wrong. Not the first time! Thanks!
              The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

              Comment


              • #22
                Originally posted by Newsbreaker View Post
                Understand, no non-scholly/mid-major has EVER made the I-AA playoff field. In the past, it has been considered next-to-impossible to do so, to the point that the Pioneer League and another have put together a contest for their champions to meet in a "bowl" game, so there's some post-season birth to shoot for.

                With that in mind, there's no reason for them NOT to schedule a game the weekend of Round 1. Every expectation is that there's no reason not to, and it means a week of football once a good portion of the nation has gone into shut down mode.

                We won't get 4 teams in guys, it's just not going to happen. Personally, I don't think 3 is likely either. Again, that would give us 1/4 of the at-large teams, leaving only 6 slots for seven other leagues to split. Unlikely.

                As an AGS voter, I feel I should way in my two cents here for whatever it's worth. IF there are 3 teams from the Gateway with 8-3 or better records, we WILL have 3 in the playoffs. There won't be a repeat of last season where YSU was left home at 8-3. 4 is very unlikely, considering all the teams play eachother, but I do not believe that this is statistically eliminated yet... 3 from the Gateway and 3-4 from the A-10 will take up a majority of the at-large spots. If UNI beats either SIU or ISU and wins the other two home games, we are a lock for the playoffs. IF ISU loses two more games, they are still a lock for the playoffs. IF SIU loses once more, they are a lock for the playoffs. IF YSU only loses once the rest of the way, they too are in the playoffs. Heck, WKU could very well pull a 2005 UNI and run the table for a spot in the playoffs. All of this is possible due to the fact that many of the "auto-bids" are struggling to find one top team, let alone worrying about getting anyone as an at-large. There is no Lafayette thus far this season like last year. And to those wondering about San Diego, I wouldn't hold my breath. The chances of them making the playoffs are about as good as Jim Harbaugh coming back to lead the Bears to the Super Bowl...

                Comment


                • #23
                  here is why i don't think San Diego will get in ... granted the selection committee changes, but i feel a precedent was set in 1996 when the University of Dayton won the PFL with an 11-0 record, and didn't make the playoffs. they were ranked 24th in the nation at the end of the season

                  they beat the following teams -
                  morehead state
                  georgetown (ky)
                  UW-plateville
                  towson state
                  evansville
                  robert morris
                  butler
                  drake
                  valpo
                  wofford (scholarship to my knowledge)
                  san diego

                  the next year ('97), they won 9 to start the year and then lost 44-24 at Cal-Poly ... coincidently, UNI lost to that Cal-Poly team 38-24 that year also

                  i just don't see the selection committee putting san diego in the field, but you never know, if they get in, they better not get embarrassed otherwise no i-aaa team will ever have a chance of getting in again.

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    uniwatcher, you unintentionally made a good argument against 4 teams getting in. There are too many head-to-head games left, meaning the Gateway teams looking for a birth have too many guaranteed future losses between them.

                    In other leagues, struggling to find a "top team" can be interpreted as universal averageness, or universal "greatness" relatively speaking. You're not going to see leagues that normally get an at-large bid suddenly shut out. It's just not going to happen...the process is far to political.

                    On another subject, can someone explain the "Any Given Saturday" poll to me. Are the voters "credentialed" in some way other then being regulars on a message board, and gaining some sort of status amoungst themselves in this way? I perceive that as nothing more then a "very interested fan" poll, but I could be misunderstanding. Isn't it a bit like finding a group of big football fans from around the country who like talking to each other, and having them put together a poll?

                    Comment


                    • #25


                      2006 Rules:
                      ------------------------------------
                      1. Must be an AGS approved member*.
                      2. Must register for the regular season poll by August 15, 2006.
                      3. Must agree to vote objectively.
                      4. Must vote for all top twenty-five places each week.
                      5. Must not miss voting more than two week's the entire regular season.
                      6. Must agree to abide by the rules and administrator decisions.
                      7. Voting must be done each week between Saturdays after all the week's games are done and Mondays at Noon (CST).
                      8. Administrators will monitor for rules abuse. Ballots and/or voting may be denied.
                      *Approved AGS members:
                      -- Posted 100 or more times by 5/1/2006 on the AGS boards.
                      ----------------------------------------------------------------

                      I think that this poll has been the most accurate out of all the polls in 1-AA for the past couple years. The preseason poll constantly beats out the other polls at the end of the year (pre vs. post-season poll comparison). Check out the GPI. It's the BCS formula for the PCS (playoff champ series). It has predicted the playoff teams (at-large bids) each year pretty well.
                      The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Originally posted by Newsbreaker View Post
                        uniwatcher, you unintentionally made a good argument against 4 teams getting in. There are too many head-to-head games left, meaning the Gateway teams looking for a birth have too many guaranteed future losses between them.

                        In other leagues, struggling to find a "top team" can be interpreted as universal averageness, or universal "greatness" relatively speaking. You're not going to see leagues that normally get an at-large bid suddenly shut out. It's just not going to happen...the process is far to political.

                        On another subject, can someone explain the "Any Given Saturday" poll to me. Are the voters "credentialed" in some way other then being regulars on a message board, and gaining some sort of status amoungst themselves in this way? I perceive that as nothing more then a "very interested fan" poll, but I could be misunderstanding. Isn't it a bit like finding a group of big football fans from around the country who like talking to each other, and having them put together a poll?
                        Yep, you pretty much figured out what the AGS poll is all about. The great thing is, that we, the fans/posters have been more accurate in our rankings over the past couple years than ANY other poll for IAA. Remember, many other schools most likely have their SID or similar individual do their "Coaches Rankings" or Newspaper Writers/Editors from a small part of the country get a vote without knowing anything about at least half the teams in IAA. That's why a fan poll/"IAA expert poll" is such a great thing. I intentionally made the arguement against 4 teams, however, I still say we get 3 (which you have stated will not happen...). 4 has not YET been statistically eliminated as a possibility, but that is PROBABLY only a matter of time. The A-10 will get AT LEAST 2 at-larges, and most likely 3. That means that 5/8 of the at-larges will most likely be from two conferences. AT LEAST 4/8 will in all likelihood be from the A-10/Gateway.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          IMO, Southland, Patriot, and OVC are 3 conferences that get one bid. So, if the A-10 and GFC take 4 autos, they are just taking the one extra from their respective conferences, and then two from this group...leaving one extra for another conference or independent.
                          The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Colgate in 03?

                            Wasn't a big deal made about Colgate making it to the final in 2003 as a nonscholarship program? Or partial? Does anyone have info regarding Colgate?

                            Thanks in advance.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Pretty sure 4 Gateway teams made it a few years ago...and then all of the schools promptly lost in the first or second round...for that reason and that reason alone, the Gateway won't get 4 in...but 3 is a possibility. News...I'll have a pair of my flip flops ready if they get 4...hopefully they'll taste nice with BBQ sauce.
                              "10% of life is what happens to you, 90% is how you react to what happens."

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Northwest Iowa Panther

                                Originally posted by Cat80 View Post
                                Wasn't a big deal made about Colgate making it to the final in 2003 as a nonscholarship program? Or partial? Does anyone have info regarding Colgate?

                                Thanks in advance.
                                I agree with you Cat. I remember watching their run through the playoffs and the announcers making a big deal out of their nonscholarship status. They were the National Runnerup that year, 2003.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X