WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

AP to allow FCS teams to be ranked

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    I agree with News & PantherFan that this is a stupid idea. Its unrealistic. ASU, while a great team, couldn't stand up to the impact of a full BCS slate. On any given week an FCS can beat an FBS but week in and week out the wear and tear would take its toll and crumble all FCS teams. The fact that FBS can give 33% more scholarships is, of course, the biggest, reason. You can not overstate the effect of that depth enough. And then of course, the "one step slower, one inch smaller" factors would begin to have some effect, eventually. So to give them a ranking is inappropriate, and is just further proof that everything in our lives is controlled by irresponsible media, IMO.

    While the one advantage I do see is the exposure forces the FBS-egomaniacs to realize that ASU (or UNI, etc) is not D-II like we so commonly hear, but is in fact D-I. But I think that advantage is far outweighed by the frankly unfair "perception" that this creates.

    Now I dont know if I buy into News' theory about where this could all lead too just yet. Afterall, the NCAA did just put a moratorium on any jumps (I believe for 5 years) but perhaps I'm wrong in assuming that would have some kind of effect on this?

    But since we're dealing in purely hypotheticals here, I agree that no doubt, if given the opportunity SOME FCS school would take the jump and play in a minor bowl.

    Either its the top tier (say seeds 1-4) trying to prove something or the mid tier thinking, "well, we can play in this bowl for $750,000 or we can try to go on the road for 4 weeks and win a title that 'nobody cares about'" (I'm speaking of national media, not FCS fans) and lose a lot of money in the process.

    Which would you take from a financial standpoint??

    If UNI can get 8,000 people to drive down to Tennessee on 6 days notice they can surely get 15,000 to go to a (perhaps) warm destination given 3 weeks to plan, right? Well, at least the first time.

    And therein lies another problem. Like we all know, unless its the "big one" bowls are basically glorified exhibitions and they are fun for the fans as a novelty item in the beginning. But a fanbase only goes so far in supporting the team after years of "MicronPC Poulan Weedeater Douche Masingil . com" Bowls. Eventually it doesn't seem that fun and you turn into the Minnesota's of the world who couldn't sell 1,000 tickets to the bowl in Arizona last year (as opposed to the estimated 40,000 Cyclone fans that attended the same bowl years earlier, their first bowl in 30 years).

    And in the end, it shows what makes the playoffs great... but only if they aren't diluted.

    Being crowned FCS National Champion because you didnt have to play (what would have been) seeds 1-4 because they played in the PoinsettiaPapaJohns.Gov Bowl taints that.

    I don't like it and its unlikely I will ever like it.

    A completly seperate argument to this is that ASU's upset will now make it even tougher to schedule an FBS opponent, willing to pay the $$$ we need them to. If an ASU can beat a Michigan than a UNI can surely beat an ISU, an Iowa, a Minnesota, etc, etc.

    While this win should be celebrated in the FCS circles, keeping it a bit more grounded would be beneficial and this ranking nonsense is just one example of something we could do without, IMO.
    Last edited by UNI MadCat; 09-07-2007, 09:56 AM.

    Comment


    • #17
      Let me make one thing clear...I'm not saying there is a "conspiracy" and plans are afoot. I'm saying this is a step, in a series on loosely related steps, in a certain direction.

      Comment


      • #18
        I don't think this is a step, it its a knee jerk reaction to ASU upsetting the #5 FBS team. Do you think they would have taken this step if that had not happened?
        GO PANTHERS!

        Comment


        • #19
          Originally posted by GonzoCat View Post
          I don't think this is a step, it its a knee jerk reaction to ASU upsetting the #5 FBS team. Do you think they would have taken this step if that had not happened?
          Step implies intent. There is no intent to head in the direction I detailed above, at least not yet.

          This is a knee-jerk reaction, but an important one in a specific direction.

          Comment


          • #20
            I wasn't trying to cast aspersions on your post, Newsy, just trying to chip my two cents with a little tongue in cheek. Because somewhere there probably is someone saying that it is an NC2A conspiracy.
            Fight! For the Purple and the Gold!
            VICTORY FOR UNI!
            UNI FIGHT! UNI FIGHT!

            Comment


            • #21
              I understand Dome, I was just trying to clarify.

              Comment


              • #22
                I think this is a bad idea, although I dont agree that this was the first step toward eliminating FCS football altogether.
                Sincerely,
                The Future AD of the University of Northern Iowa

                Comment


                • #23
                  Originally posted by Cat80 View Post
                  I had to ask a guy: Is Georgetown in D I? The answer was yes. I then asked is UNI in D I? The answer was no. I then asked why did they play each other in the NCAA BB tournament? Confusion set in......
                  Very funny.
                  Sincerely,
                  The Future AD of the University of Northern Iowa

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    It's never said anything about a "subdivision" poll. It's always just been the AP College Football poll...by that definition...Mount Union College in Ohio could be ranked. Why not? They might be one of the best teams.
                    "10% of life is what happens to you, 90% is how you react to what happens."

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by panther2317 View Post
                      It's never said anything about a "subdivision" poll. It's always just been the AP College Football poll...by that definition...Mount Union College in Ohio could be ranked. Why not? They might be one of the best teams.
                      Because they aren't one of the best. Just like an ASU isn't one of the best. I'm sorry but its just not possible. ASU was better than Michigan last Saturday. They even be good enough to beat them again down the road. But in a 12-game BCS-type schedule ASU starts losing every game down the stretch due to lack of numbers. Its not a slight, its just the truth. 63 is a lot less than 85 and that takes its toll.

                      And this knee-jerk "amendment" (or basically, "clarification") further fuels the perception that there isn't a difference and that we should all just be D-I and compete for the same prizes.

                      While it seems positive in the short run, its a negative in the long run.

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        That's pretty close to saying that Boise State should never be able to play for the BCS Championship because they play in a lesser conference vs. lesser competition. That stinks of an elitist way of thinking. We ARE all Division 1 football. It's a Division 1 football poll.

                        Your assertion that "in a 12-game BCS-type schedule" ASU starts losing every game down the stretch is ludicrous. They're not joining the Big Ten. Hell, they could play a Sun Belt schedule and I think they'd win the league. Would they deserve to be ranked if they were in the Sun Belt, beat Michigan on the road and then won the Sun Belt? If you're answer for that scenario is "yes", then why can't they be one of the best 25 teams as we are right now?
                        "10% of life is what happens to you, 90% is how you react to what happens."

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Thanks, I have a headache now

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Originally posted by panther2317 View Post
                            That's pretty close to saying that Boise State should never be able to play for the BCS Championship because they play in a lesser conference vs. lesser competition. That stinks of an elitist way of thinking. We ARE all Division 1 football. It's a Division 1 football poll.
                            Totally different. This isn't a conference vs. conference agruement, it's comparing different groupings within a division based on number of scholorships, revenue streams, resources, etc. Of course Boise St. SHOULD be allowed to play for a BCS championship if they're judged to be good enough - it's the same division (or subdivision in this case). Not trying to speak for you, but you seem to be making a major vs. mid-major arguement, similar to basketball. Using that logic, you can't compare Boise St. with Appy St. - different subdivisions, hence nothing analogous to basketball.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              There is good football in the "FBS".
                              There is good football in the "FCS".
                              There is good football in the FCS non-scholarship leagues.
                              There is good football in D2.
                              And there is good football in D3.

                              The differences are the number of resources allowed to be allotted to football (in this case, scholarships). And there are reasons for those distinctions.

                              Frankly, I like the FCS level (despite hating the new name), because it is high-quality football, but it hasn't totally whored itself out to the corporations and "almighty dollar" like the FBS seems to have.

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                FCS schools should NOT be included in the FBS polls. Just the same, FBS schools should not be allowed in FCS polls. Come on folks, if Iowa State beats us Saturday should they be ranked in the FCS poll??? Separate divisions, separate polls. I personally like the fact that UNI is a top 5 / top 10 team each and every year. If the polls were condensed we wouldn't even sniff a ranking....ever.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X