WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Does a Verbal Commitment Matter Anymore?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Does a Verbal Commitment Matter Anymore?



    Interesting article. Thoughts?
    The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

  • #2
    I found that article very confusing.
    GO PANTHERS!

    Comment


    • #3
      I agree Gonzo................the coaches (supposedly) back off and honor it, why shouldn't the recruited player honor it. He's kind of comparing apples and oranges when he drags in the coaches. They signed a "contract". The player, by committing, means we stop recruiting for that scholarship. When someone backs out of a commitment, someone is snooping around (that compares favorably with coaches)!
      Lettin' the cat outta the bag is a whole lot easier'n puttin' it back.

      Before you wonder "Am I doing things right," ask "Am I doing the right things?"

      Comment


      • #4
        Someone needs to have a grammar class for coaches and players and teach them the meaning of the words "VERBAL COMMITMENT". When you agree to attend a college...all recruiting should cease. The kid and their family should cancel all other visits, not take phone calls from other coaches (except to tell them they've decided to go somewhere else) and coaches should not continue recruiting efforts once a kid has made a very tough decision.

        I'd like to see more honesty and integrity in recruiting. I know I won't, but a guy can dream can't he?
        "10% of life is what happens to you, 90% is how you react to what happens."

        Comment


        • #5
          2317, I understand why you're saying that. However, verbal is just that - verbal. Just like in business, if there's no ink on paper, then there's no contract. A college coach would argue that there's too much money and win/losses at stake not to keep selling, even though the player's already supposedly made up his mind. While you and I might not agree with this tactic, it's reality, and the only way to stop it is for the NCAA to mandate against it.

          It's also a two way street. If the original school has "sold" a superior situation, then it's the player's responsibility to not accept any other calls.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
            2317, I understand why you're saying that. However, verbal is just that - verbal. Just like in business, if there's no ink on paper, then there's no contract.
            Technically, that's not what I learned in Business Law I & II at UNI. Hard to enforce perhaps, but in business a verbal agreement is legally binding if it can be proved.

            What was that guys name? Telford? Can't remember if that was his first or last name.
            Last edited by GonzoCat; 11-10-2006, 10:48 AM.
            GO PANTHERS!

            Comment


            • #7
              Semantics perhaps, Gonzo. I'm in tech sales, and there's no way I could ever install something for a customer, or hold them to anything, based on a verbal "yes" to a sale. Only a countersigned contract counts legally. Of course, it's possible that the nature of the deal (business vs. personal) may matter. In MB's case, he didn't breach any agreement, as there was no contract to breach. I'm no lawyer, however, so just going by experience.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
                Semantics perhaps, Gonzo. I'm in tech sales

                If you dont mind...what kind of sales and where at?

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by GonzoCat View Post
                  Technically, that's not what I learned in Business Law I & II at UNI. Hard to enforce perhaps, but in business a verbal agreement is legally binding if it can be proved.

                  What was that guys name? Telford? Can't remember if that was his first or last name.
                  I'm going with Gonzo on this one. A contract has three parts: offer, acceptance and consideration. Oral, written, explicit and implied contracts can all be legally binding. Now maybe not in all cases for evey circumstance - such as your tech sales business. But even look at the Uniform Commercial Code... there's a lot of stuff that can be binding without ever being written down when it comes to the phrase 'commercially reasonable manner'.

                  Oh, the UCC.... why did I ever type that on PN...

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
                    2317, I understand why you're saying that. However, verbal is just that - verbal. Just like in business, if there's no ink on paper, then there's no contract. A college coach would argue that there's too much money and win/losses at stake not to keep selling, even though the player's already supposedly made up his mind. While you and I might not agree with this tactic, it's reality, and the only way to stop it is for the NCAA to mandate against it.

                    It's also a two way street. If the original school has "sold" a superior situation, then it's the player's responsibility to not accept any other calls.
                    Stein...you're focusing on the wrong word...I look at commitment more than verbal. If you're not ready to COMMIT, then you keep your recruitment open. If you're ready to COMMIT...you verbal and then sign. It really is that simple.
                    "10% of life is what happens to you, 90% is how you react to what happens."

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Guess not....


                      I really don't like this kind of stuff, even if it benefits UNI.
                      The Lord reigns, let the earth be glad; let the distant shores rejoice, clouds and thick darkness surround Him; righteousness and justice are the foundation of His throne. Fire goes before Him, and consumes his foes on every side; His lightning lights up the world; the earth sees and trembles; the mountains melt like wax before the Lord of all the earth. The heavens proclaim His righteousness and all peoples will see His glory.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by panther2317 View Post
                        Stein...you're focusing on the wrong word...I look at commitment more than verbal. If you're not ready to COMMIT, then you keep your recruitment open. If you're ready to COMMIT...you verbal and then sign. It really is that simple.
                        2317, I think we mostly agree here, just looking at it from a different perspective. I'm looking at it purely from a business transactional standpoint. At the end of the day, that's exactly what it is, a contract to do business together, ie. a closed sale. I totally agree with you that ethically the kid shouldn't verbally commit and wait for a perceived better deal. Whether it's Mike B. or the wrestler in PTTB's link above, backing out puts the program in a bind because they probably back off on other guys who would honor their verbals. I've also heard of coaches yanking scholorships offers away, or threatening to, if a kid doesn't make up his mind within a set timeframe. I guess it works both ways.

                        Comment

                        Working...
                        X