WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Grant Gibbs

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Re: Grant Gibbs

    [B]Originally posted by LukeFeddersenThe question is do you think it was something intentional done by the opposition?

    When I first read that question my knee jerk reaction went two ways. Why would someone intentionally do that? The other was that it wouldn't shock me coming from East to have something like that happen. However, that is some bad stereotyping on my part.

    The first three times I watched the tape of it, it looked just like stated by savages, that it was just a dunk that he was going to fast and didn't get a good enough grip on. However there was something odd about it as I kept watching it. I noticed that the East player going for the block from the back side seemed to have a strange landing as well. I had to watch it a couple more times, and it took me a couple tries but I paused it and screen shotted it to show you what I mean.


    I know it is not of great quality but bear with it. This is right before Gibbs flies uncontrollably towards the cameraman. I believe that it is Trice going for the block behind him, at least it looks like a number four. Notice how his right leg is thrown out to the side and extended behind Gibbs. And if you watch that leg closely in the video his leg does make a seemingly intentional swipe at Gibbs. A very scary side kick if you will, that happens to catch Gibbs in the left hamstring.

    I realize this could be a serious accusation on my part, and could be completely wrong. However, knowing what I know about Trice and the attitude he tends to carry on the court, it wouldn't shock me. In fact he did something very similar in the Dubuque Hempstead game at East last year. A Hemp player had the ball on a fast break and as he went up for the dunk Trice jumped on his back, wrapped his arms around his shoulders and tackled him to the ground. He then talked some crap to the player as he laid on the ground in pain, and walked away with a cocky swagger.

    Again I could be very very wrong, and these accusations could be very bad on my part. However I think it was intentional. Whether it was meant to go to that degree I'm not sure.
    Last edited by clenz; 01-23-2008, 09:14 PM.

    Comment


    • #17
      Re: Grant Gibbs

      I am not trying to start anything here but...

      If it would have been Dubuque Wahlert (or any other MVC school) instead of Waterloo East, no one would be having this discussion. It would have been a kid trying to make a play and Gibbs ended up getting hurt.

      I have watched it multiple times and I just don't buy that it was in any way intentional. It was a combination of Gibbs momentum and a late jump by Scott...

      Comment


      • #18
        Re: Grant Gibbs

        Luke seems to be putting himself out their on this one.

        Comment


        • #19
          Re: Grant Gibbs

          I'm just telling you, watch the legs on the jump. I've never seen Trice throw his legs out like that on his jumps

          Comment


          • #20
            Re: Grant Gibbs

            I know Luke fairly well and I believe he supports the HS players better than anyone in the State, for him to publicly question this play says a lot. I guess we will have to see if the IAHSAA has any reaction to the play.

            Comment


            • #21
              Re: Grant Gibbs

              Gibbs signed with Gonzaga !?
              Career (3 sport) Coaching Record: 50-3
              the Future coach of the Depaul Blue Demons

              Comment


              • #22
                Re: Grant Gibbs

                Here is video of the incident. Watch the way Trice kicks his leg out at Grants leg. Seems fishy to me, and a couple others on the IowaPreps OTR



                (Click the red camera on the right)

                Comment


                • #23
                  Re: Grant Gibbs

                  Gibbs broke his shooting wrist(right) but did not require surgery.

                  Here is the article in todays Gazette, he might be back for the state tourney.
                  GO PANTHERS!!

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Re: Grant Gibbs

                    Originally posted by panther2317
                    I think its horrible to accuse a kid of intentionally hurting an opponent. We've got one angle of grainy video. Were you there? I talked to a guy from Linn-Mar who just said that he went in too fast and came down wrong. They didn't think there was any ill done by an East player.
                    Having seen Mr. Scott play, I would disagree. He is a thug on the court and watching that video suggests that he went after Gibbs. How in the world can you think anything else seeing the way he kicks his legs out there!? Having talked to a couple of folks at the game, the general feeling is that Scott tried to take him out on the play; hopefully he didn't mean to cause such a serious injury...

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Re: Grant Gibbs

                      Originally posted by Brett Crawford View Post
                      It wasn't an undercut...

                      The East kid just appeared to jump late to try to block the shot and Gibbs fell awkwardly, Gibbs was in incredible pain...
                      Yes, he "jumped late" and then took his leg and tried to kick Gibbs. Flagrant foul at the very least...

                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Re: Grant Gibbs

                        Originally posted by UNI05Alum View Post
                        Having talked to a couple of folks at the game, the general feeling is that Scott tried to take him out on the play; hopefully he didn't mean to cause such a serious injury...
                        Were these Linn-Mar fans?

                        If it was intentional, there would have been a foul, ejected, something called. One 30 second clip or a fuzzy still picture cannot be enough evidence to accuse somebody of this. If Scott is jumping from a different angle trying to caught up and make a play, his leg or legs may go different directions.

                        I have watched the video as many times as the next guy and not once did the thought come to my mind that this was an intentional act. Grant's motentum carried him to far and he fell. We see in the pros and in college all the time.

                        I feel for Grant and hoep for a speedy recovery.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Re: Grant Gibbs

                          Are we even sure Scott's leg hit Gibbs?

                          I watched the video many times and I couldn't tell 100% if they even made contact. Yes, Scott's jump looked akward, but so did Gibbs'. Gibbs' momentum seemed to take his lower body too far in front and when he let go of the rim, it brought him down head first.

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Re: Grant Gibbs

                            All I can say is, "Back and to the left...back and to the left...back and to the left". If he wanted to "take him out" he would have done it differently than that, I think. He could have just undercut him and gotten it over with. Gibbs made a great play that ended up bad due to his momentum. Happens all the time.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              Re: Grant Gibbs

                              Here are some opinions from people at on preps that were at the game. He is from neither Linn-Mar or East

                              I was at the game....Trice didnt get a T after he fouled out, McGraw (the head coach) got one...but trice must have said something because Mcgraw was screaming at him on the bench as was another man, not an assistant, but the way he was walking around during the game I think he was easts AD. I dont think the game was very physical at all really, but I do agree that trice somehow hit/kicked/pushed gibbs on the dunk. because in person you could see a lot of contact and it looked like he was undercut...on the video though it didnt look as much as he was undercut, you can hardly tell contact was made on it, but there was contact.

                              While it is hard to tell how much contact there was, I've seen Trice play enough and met him enough to know that it isn't past him to do something like that. He isn't one to usually just go after someone like he did in the Hempsted example I used. He is very sly with sneaking feet under players as they are coming down, or getting some "good" elbows in to a player. It would be a perfect way to take him out without it being obvious. He is going up for a dunk on a fast break, make it look like I went for a block and if I get called for a foul my momentum carried me and it was an accident.

                              Again, like I said I can't say for sure he did it on purpose, however I'm saying it is a likely chance. I hate to stereotype, but East would be the school to do it too.

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Re: Grant Gibbs

                                I've also been told it looked about 10 times worse in person than on "One 30 second clip or a fuzzy still picture"

                                Just look at the way Trice's leg is cocked out to the side and how it gets brought across the body in a kicking motion. Trice doesn't jump like that

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X