WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #61
    Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

    Originally posted by ubuntuCAT View Post
    Is anyone really questioning why NDSU is doing this if they have the ability? Of course any school would if they could. Most of the discussion is around having a conference wide stance on COA.
    Would you feel the same way if they had just announced they were building a brand new practice facility or a brand new player lounge? Maybe not a direct correlation, but they could be viewed as recruiting tools just as well. Look at our brand new shiny stadium and all the facilities our players have access too compared to so and so. Should the conference decide what the schools are allowed to build as well?

    Comment


    • #62
      Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

      Originally posted by otter View Post
      Would you feel the same way if they had just announced they were building a brand new practice facility or a brand new player lounge? Maybe not a direct correlation, but they could be viewed as recruiting tools just as well. Look at our brand new shiny stadium and all the facilities our players have access too compared to so and so. Should the conference decide what the schools are allowed to build as well?
      apples to oranges. To my knowledge there is no conference that dictates what facilities it's members can build. Actual payments to players is a much bigger deal and immensely better competitive advantage than a nicer players lounge IMO.

      NDSU recruiters can now say on top of your scholarship we will hand you $3,400 to do whatever you want with. Every year. And nobody else in the conference will offer you that.
      "I think they're very good," Farley said of the preseason top 25 Hawkeyes. "But so are we."

      Comment


      • #63
        Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

        Did Appy State make the jump up and dominate right away? NOPE

        They struggled at first, but I think they are slowly becoming competitive in the Sun Belt. I could see NDSU maybe being competitive in the Sun Belt, but all other leagues they would struggle. Yes I get it they beat FBS Iowa State and other decent teams but that's 1 game vs FBS. Try going an entire 12 game schedule and it would be different.

        The only conference that I think would accept NDSU would be the Mountain West. Big 12, Big Ten, and even the Big East wouldn't want that. Too far to travel and the other teams in the league would not like that one bit having to travel to Fargo late in the year and play. I realize they have a Dome, but they would need to upgrade it and put more seats in it. Aren't there requirements for stadiums to have a minimum seating capacity. Guessing 20,000+ for the smaller leagues.

        Comment


        • #64
          Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

          Originally posted by ubuntuCAT View Post
          apples to oranges. To my knowledge there is no conference that dictates what facilities it's members can build. Actual payments to players is a much bigger deal and immensely better competitive advantage than a nicer players lounge IMO.

          NDSU recruiters can now say on top of your scholarship we will hand you $3,400 to do whatever you want with. Every year. And nobody else in the conference will offer you that.
          How is that even fair?? Once again it should be an all conference thing or not allowed. If all schools don't do it, then one shouldn't be allowed to.

          Comment


          • #65
            Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

            Originally posted by PantherHawk View Post
            Did Appy State make the jump up and dominate right away? NOPE

            They struggled at first, but I think they are slowly becoming competitive in the Sun Belt. I could see NDSU maybe being competitive in the Sun Belt, but all other leagues they would struggle. Yes I get it they beat FBS Iowa State and other decent teams but that's 1 game vs FBS. Try going an entire 12 game schedule and it would be different.

            The only conference that I think would accept NDSU would be the Mountain West. Big 12, Big Ten, and even the Big East wouldn't want that. Too far to travel and the other teams in the league would not like that one bit having to travel to Fargo late in the year and play. I realize they have a Dome, but they would need to upgrade it and put more seats in it. Aren't there requirements for stadiums to have a minimum seating capacity. Guessing 20,000+ for the smaller leagues.
            1. ASU was in their first season of the Sun Belt last year, along with GSU. They finished 1-2 in the conference.

            2. Big East hasn't been a conference in a couple seasons

            3. This board has gone full *insert naughty word* over this topic....wow.

            Comment


            • #66
              Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

              Originally posted by GonzoCat View Post
              That's a pretty insightful post. Especially the blurb about oil. I assume the boom that has been going on in ND, and by extension at NDSU, has been largely based on a newfound oil economy. That's expensive oil they're harvesting up there, but at over $100 it's well worth it. If oil stays cheap long enough the whole state could dry up and go back to being the nothing it was for so long. There's a worldwide glut of oil right now and the middle east countries where oil basically flows free haven't even gotten desperate yet.
              This is true, along with what News wrote. Many in the world were betting on China's economy continuing a hockey stick curve upward. That's now seriously in doubt, with China's rise now potentially seen as a bubble about to burst. This is important since there were supposed to be a jillion new cars and drivers in China over the next decade. With their semi-centralized economy potentially collapsing (my God, what a shock), none of the peasants will have money to buy cars and buy lots of plastic goods. A lot of infrastructure spending (ie. North Dakota) was in essence betting on China, and it's also partially why oil was around $100 a barrel a couple of years ago.

              Comment


              • #67
                Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                I imagine the phones are on fire in St Louis. Even if NDSU kept this quiet so as to spring it on everyone (it's easier to ask forgiveness than permission, and all that), this is still a massive league failure. It's the commissioner's job to be PROACTIVE.

                Comment


                • #68
                  Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                  Originally posted by Newsbreaker View Post
                  This is like finger banging ugly sue and pretending it means you could score with supermodels. You've done fine in a bad, bad, bad, bad league. If you're getting into the men's tournament with double-digit seeds every time, no one thinks much of you.

                  Note that of those, only basketball shows sustained "success."

                  You still haven't solved the problem that will prevent you from going anywhere though. You bring nothing remarkable from a visibility (you're embarrassing, if anything) or revenue standpoint, while doubling the footprint of either league that could make any sense.

                  Not only that, but you're talking about going from being a bus destination to an airplane destination, in a town decidedly not set up for it. The only westward connection is a commuter flight to Denver, and the only eastern coverage is the same to Chicago. You can't be both (a) of limited value and (b) a pain in the arse to get to.

                  The worst of it is, you can't fix either of those things. You might want to find a way to match your ambition to your prospects.

                  Football wise. for the fun of it, lets say NDSU gets into the big 12 or Mountain West.

                  5 home games in fargo : you fly to fargo 1 time every 2 years. Big Deal:

                  NDSU fly's everywhere already:

                  TV Market wise, Lawrence, Manhattan & freakin Ames can do it, surely Fargo/Minnesota/SD could do it..... guess what here's a lil secret. NDSU football on tv getting bigger "SHARES" then most FBS teams already!
                  UNI has #2 Dome in MVFC, but Ice Lounge rocks! BisoNation.com

                  Comment


                  • #69
                    Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                    The best way to make yourself competitive is to make sure no one gains an advantage over you. Pull them back down to your level, and don't try to elevate yourself to their level. It's how this country was built. You guys have it right.

                    Please, keep whining and complaining about this. Don't donate any more money to your program. It will eventually fix itself. God bless UNI, and God bless America.

                    Comment


                    • #70
                      Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                      If NDSU could string together 2-3 good basketball seasons in a row, they would be in the MWC.
                      __________________
                      The McLoud Center -Bob Lutz, Wichita Eagle, 2/3/2010

                      Comment


                      • #71
                        Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                        Generally I'm not for FCS FB COA. FCS FB is specifically setup for a reason - Allow participation in the D1 basketball tourney , and provide scholarship FB (and other sports).

                        The need for the COA thing is overblown IMO. It uses anecdotes to prove a generality - i.e., poor Tommy plays for Notre Dame, but can't afford to go home to see mom.

                        Kids have the opportunity to leave debt free (or greatly reduced) with a college education, of varying quality. The are definite tradeoffs in time, effort, and risk of injury in any sport. But that is a choice they make knowing the rules going in. It's definitely not easy, but if it were easy, I would have 4 national championship rings as UNI's QB.

                        Comment


                        • #72
                          Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                          Originally posted by ubuntuCAT View Post
                          All of the MVC is paying in basketball not just UNI.
                          So you guys are Socialists...

                          Comment


                          • #73
                            Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                            Originally posted by Unionpanther View Post
                            I'm very surprised they didn't need to get the Conference's approval for this. It basically amounts to a recruiting advantage over all the other schools that don't offer it. I checked their roster last year and they had somewhere on the order of 50+ kids from MN and WI playing for them. How? They have tuition reciprocity for students from Mn and Wi and don't have to pay out of state tuition from their football budget. Now they are giving money to kids (which is ok) but they need to have all conference schools do it or no one does it.

                            BTW, here is an article about moving up:http://www.ehow.com/list_6660709_div...uirements.html Basically, you need to average 15,000 attendance in football, fill 90% of your football scholarship allotment, have 200 scholarships costing a minimum of $4 million over 16 varsity sports.

                            Also, Lakes- NDSU is in the Big 12 wrestling QUALIFIER. The Big 12 lost their qualifier status and had to add teams or go with at-large invitations. They aren't actually part of the conference. You won't see OSU or Ok coming to Fargo for a meet anytime soon (not that Kish would want to be destroyed by teams literally out of NDSU's league on a regular basis anyway.) They also don't enjoy any of the benefits of conference membership either, namely $ to member schools.

                            And I'll add this: the little engine that could, NDSU, will eventually run out of steam. It is inevitable. So enjoy your day in the sun, you've earned it, but be prepared for the what happens on the way down.
                            Holy crap the butthurt is strong here

                            Comment


                            • #74
                              Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                              What is the Bison fan fascination with the term "butthurt"? That fell out of favor in 8th grade.

                              Comment


                              • #75
                                Re: NDSU going to start giving stipends in all sports

                                Hey troll, I will refer you to last year's score and the melt down that took place within bizon nation if you are looking for an example of butthurt. Now do us a favor and take Lakes back with you to Bowbells and let the grown ups discuss this matter.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X