WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

    Originally posted by claw View Post
    That's short term thinking, and it's only going to create more and more visious cycles of lower lows that start to more than cancel the highs over a couple recruiting cycles.

    4 NIT seasons will do more for recruiting slightly higher level prospects than 2 17 or 18 win seasons followed by a 24 and 26 win season only to be followed by another 17 win season. That pattern is picked up on by recruits. They then decided that they don't want half of their career to be spent at a .500 program. They'd rather pick the 21-24 win team that is NIT/NCAA bubble every year. Eventually that builds into a consistent NCAA team.
    That could happen, and that would be great. Or you could devolve into an Illinois State or Missouri State situation where you never have any real highs.

    As a recruit, I'd rather play for a team that I know is building to two good years (and I would be a part of that development process), than a team that is going to tread water the entire time I was there.

    Recruits pick up on the fact that we went the the NCAAs twice and were ranked, do they really pick up on the fact that Illinois State is above average on consistent basis? Maybe, I don't know. Something to think about though. If what it takes to be successful at our level is to give people more opportunities early on and suffer through some more lean years in order to get to the good ones I will take it. The experience McCloud and McDonnell, Haldeman and Brown got this year could pay dividends in 2019 and 2020.

    I see the point you are making, just playing devils advocate and offering another perspective.

    Comment


    • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

      Originally posted by UNIGrainer View Post
      That could happen, and that would be great. Or you could devolve into an Illinois State or Missouri State situation where you never have any real highs.

      As a recruit, I'd rather play for a team that I know is building to two good years (and I would be a part of that development process), than a team that is going to tread water the entire time I was there.

      Recruits pick up on the fact that we went the the NCAAs twice and were ranked, do they really pick up on the fact that Illinois State is above average on consistent basis? Maybe, I don't know. Something to think about though. If what it takes to be successful at our level is to give people more opportunities early on and suffer through some more lean years in order to get to the good ones I will take it. The experience McCloud and McDonnell, Haldeman and Brown got this year could pay dividends in 2019 and 2020.

      I see the point you are making, just playing devils advocate and offering another perspective.
      Another perspective would be that when the 6 guys leave you have at least 4 that have been seeing minutes and are talented enough to step in and run the show without suffering two 17 win season in the process. Those 4 would also be able to carry the load while the newer recruits get acclimated and then the process repeats itself.

      Comment


      • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

        Originally posted by BCPanther View Post
        The one blessing of Wyatt's injury is that it puts a scholarship into the class of '19. We weren't going to have one that year.

        Correct me if I'm wrong but I think this is where we're at:
        2018-4 (Koch, Carlson, Friedman, Rhodes)
        2019-1 (W Lohaus)
        2020-6 (Haldeman, McCloud, Brown, Dahl, McDonnell, McDermott)
        2021-3 (T Lohaus, Phyfe, 1 to give)

        Yes, I know that there's 14 listed but McDermott won't have a ride this year and of course Phyfe could move into 2022. I don't see anyway the one to get doesn't play this year unless it's a transfer.

        Maybe it is just me, but it was a bit unsettling to already be thinking about the recruiting class to replace Phyfe!

        Comment


        • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

          Originally posted by UNIdad View Post
          Maybe it is just me, but it was a bit unsettling to already be thinking about the recruiting class to replace Phyfe!
          I still think we see Phyfe redshirt. His dad would like to see him redshirt (per the Driving the Lane podcast). I think that unless he is a 20 MPG type player he redshirts this year.

          Austin at 22-23 is so much better than him at 18-19

          Comment


          • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

            Yep, I wasn't sold on the redshirt until I learned Steve was on board. Its obviously been discussed and Steve himself got huge returns by using his transfer/redshirt year.

            Comment


            • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

              There just isn't or shouldn't be enough min for him to even get. We have 3 true bigs of which 1 is solid, one is kinda unknown but shown some good flashes, and then Ted...Great D but a liability with how bad we are on O. If you add Klint to that list when we play small that's 4 guys and 3 of which should be able to hold it down just fine. Luke also is an option at 5 but much better if he stays at the 4.He helps our program much more by redshirting this year and playing the 25-30 min the following year. I get why ppl struggle with it because he has ability but the upside of a redshirt year is huge!

              Comment


              • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                Assuming Bennett learns not to foul he will be a 30 minute guy - up from 20 this year. That eats up whatever extra minutes there may have been.

                Comment


                • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                  Originally posted by claw View Post
                  Assuming Bennett learns not to foul he will be a 30 minute guy - up from 20 this year. That eats up whatever extra minutes there may have been.
                  You mean he learns to stop getting hit in the face and somehow gets the foul called on him?

                  Comment


                  • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                    Originally posted by BCPanther View Post
                    You mean he learns to stop getting hit in the face and somehow gets the foul called on him?
                    Right. Learns to stop fouling.

                    Comment


                    • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                      Originally posted by claw View Post
                      Right. Learns to stop fouling.
                      I still remember a game, @Indiana State two years ago, where Bennett picked up two fouls in quick succession by getting elbowed in the face twice in one minute.

                      Comment


                      • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                        Originally posted by sevelev711 View Post
                        I still remember a game, @Indiana State two years ago, where Bennett picked up two fouls in quick succession by getting elbowed in the face twice in one minute.
                        A) As some mention. Refs love to call fouls on Bennett.
                        B) He also does quite a few dumb things to get fouls called on him.

                        I understand the redshirt Phyfe argument. My concern is if he is the 2nd best 5 option he needs to play since we know Koch will get in trouble. Luke can play the 5 but really is a 4. Ted can play good D but a black whole on O. Verdict out on Dahl still.

                        Comment


                        • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                          Originally posted by DownGoesKansas View Post
                          A) As some mention. Refs love to call fouls on Bennett.
                          B) He also does quite a few dumb things to get fouls called on him.

                          I understand the redshirt Phyfe argument. My concern is if he is the 2nd best 5 option he needs to play since we know Koch will get in trouble. Luke can play the 5 but really is a 4. Ted can play good D but a black whole on O. Verdict out on Dahl still.
                          If we can get 10 serviceable minutes out of the combination of Friedman and Dahl combined, we can redshirt Phyfe. We'll still have plenty of minutes where we play small with Carlson or McDonnell at the 5 with 4 guards.

                          I was hesitant too, but if I can have 25 minutes a game from 23 year old Austin Phyfe or 8 minutes a game out of 19 year old Austin Phyfe, I know which one I'm taking.

                          Comment


                          • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                            Originally posted by DownGoesKansas View Post
                            A) As some mention. Refs love to call fouls on Bennett.
                            B) He also does quite a few dumb things to get fouls called on him.

                            I understand the redshirt Phyfe argument. My concern is if he is the 2nd best 5 option he needs to play since we know Koch will get in trouble. Luke can play the 5 but really is a 4. Ted can play good D but a black whole on O. Verdict out on Dahl still.
                            Koch, Dahl, Friedman at the 5 for minutes.

                            We have Carlson, Lohaus, McDonnell and Conrey in sticky situations at the 4.

                            McDonnell and Carlson can move to the 5 in times of need.

                            There are 5 players on the roster than can play the 5. There are 4 that can play the 4. That means there are 9 players who have already used a redshirt/won't redshirt on the roster for next year.

                            Why in the hell would we use Phyfe for 8-10 minutes per game with that kind of roster build?

                            If Phyfe is the second option in the post, across the board, that means he will be playing 15-20, or more, minutes per game. That is a situation where almost all of us would agree it is "acceptable" for him to not redshirt.

                            Also we have to consider that after this year Koch, Carlson and Friedman are gone. There are going to be a ton of minutes open the year after and who knows what can happen moving forward. It is almost always better to have a 23 year old version of the player on the court than the 19 year old version
                            Last edited by claw; 04-13-2017, 05:40 PM.

                            Comment


                            • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                              Originally posted by BCPanther View Post
                              If we can get 10 serviceable minutes out of the combination of Friedman and Dahl combined, we can redshirt Phyfe. We'll still have plenty of minutes where we play small with Carlson or McDonnell at the 5 with 4 guards.

                              I was hesitant too, but if I can have 25 minutes a game from 23 year old Austin Phyfe or 8 minutes a game out of 19 year old Austin Phyfe, I know which one I'm taking.
                              I am not sold either way. But IF he really is the 2nd best 5 and 2nd to 3rd best 4. For say 10 - 15 mins a game. I think he has to play.

                              -It makes this team better.
                              -And next year when everyone graduates, you are not starting a center with no D1 experience.
                              -Yes. It would be nice to have him that 5th year obviuosly but the earlier benefits might outweigh that. And we have about 12 scholarships to give to find that replacement.

                              Maybe he's not good enough yet and this is pointless. I just don't think either option is necesarily incorrect.

                              Comment


                              • Re: Official 2017 Panther Basketball Recruit List

                                Originally posted by DownGoesKansas View Post
                                I am not sold either way. But IF he really is the 2nd best 5 and 2nd to 3rd best 4. For say 10 - 15 mins a game. I think he has to play.

                                -It makes this team better.
                                -And next year when everyone graduates, you are not starting a center with no D1 experience.
                                -Yes. It would be nice to have him that 5th year obviuosly but the earlier benefits might outweigh that. And we have about 12 scholarships to give to find that replacement.

                                Maybe he's not good enough yet and this is pointless. I just don't think either option is necesarily incorrect.
                                Totally agree with this. There are certainly pros and cons to both approaches. I think the fact he's 15 minutes from home make the decision even more difficult, its not like an Isaiah Brown that distance forces your hand.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X