WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Class of 2017--Football Recruits

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

    Originally posted by panther1 View Post
    You are not alone...
    Ditto. Kaboom

    Comment


    • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

      a) I have full faith in Farley screwing this up
      b) Being able to run is good. But can he pass.? Sanders could run when need be.

      Comment


      • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

        The kid sounds like a really good athlete. At 6'4 with some wheels, there are a variety of spots he could play if QB doesn't work out. Having a couple guys like that on a roster is a good thing.

        Any idea what schools were interested in him for basketball? Guessing DII/low major level, but that interest shows some athleticism.

        Comment


        • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

          Originally posted by SteinPizza View Post
          Any idea what schools were interested in him for basketball? Guessing DII/low major level, but that interest shows some athleticism.
          Siena and Vermont offered according to this article: http://www.chicagotribune.com/sports...901-story.html

          Comment


          • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

            Originally posted by DownGoesKansas View Post
            a) I have full faith in Farley screwing this up
            b) Being able to run is good. But can he pass.? Sanders could run when need be.
            Point B is key.

            There's a massive difference in being able to scramble/create while being a passer and being a running QB. I'm deeply afraid of a running QB, and Farley's infatuation with them.

            Comment


            • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

              Originally posted by DownGoesKansas View Post
              a) I have full faith in Farley screwing this up
              b) Being able to run is good. But can he pass.? Sanders could run when need be.
              After reading more and trying to find more info on Keller, Farley really seemed infatuiated with his size at the QB position, for going at him that hard there doesn't seem to be a lot if evidence that he is a passer at the next level. He only had one other offer and it feels like his first choice is BB and that we were just a last minute safety valve. For someone that big there is no zip on the ball and only looks at his one option unless he has to scramble. Hope we don't go backwards to a running QB , but maybe Farley thinks Klien can work on his passing skills? Having a terrific athlete like this kid on a the team is always a plus for sure tho.

              Comment


              • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                I think that he has better throwing ability then Rennie, Carnes, or Bailey ever did. He will also be throwing to bigger receivers than those 3 ever did. I think Eli starts the next two years, and then this kid along with the two we brought in last year will have a chance to play.

                Comment


                • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                  Originally posted by achrist70 View Post
                  I think that he has better throwing ability then Rennie, Carnes, or Bailey ever did. He will also be throwing to bigger receivers than those 3 ever did. I think Eli starts the next two years, and then this kid along with the two we brought in last year will have a chance to play.
                  As does my 5 year old. We're not clearing a huge hurdle here.

                  I will say the Rennie could kind of throw the deep ball, but had absolutely no touch on anything else...

                  Comment


                  • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                    Originally posted by BCPanther View Post
                    As does my 5 year old. We're not clearing a huge hurdle here.

                    I will say the Rennie could kind of throw the deep ball, but had absolutely no touch on anything else...
                    To me he has better touch than those 3, now I am getting this off of highlight films, so there isn't any ugly to see, but he makes the "easy" throws, something that those 3 couldn't do regularly, or at all.

                    Comment


                    • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                      Originally posted by achrist70 View Post
                      I think that he has better throwing ability then Rennie, Carnes, or Bailey ever did. He will also be throwing to bigger receivers than those 3 ever did. I think Eli starts the next two years, and then this kid along with the two we brought in last year will have a chance to play.
                      Carnes and Bailey had zero passing ability, so that's not saying much. Rennie simply didn't have the arm strength/control.

                      Almost never does a run first QB win at the FCS level.

                      Look at the champions
                      JMU 2016:
                      Bryan ScHore played 14 games, completed 73% of his passes (217-297) for 3,002 yards 29 TD to 6 INT. Yes, he could run but it wasn't his primary move. Taking out sacks he ran 106 times for about 840 yards and 10 TDs. He was the most run heavy QB to win a title since 09

                      NDSU 2011-2015:
                      We all know about Wentz and Jensen (even stick) Could move if had too, and were good at it, but weren't runners.

                      EWU 2010:
                      Bo Levi Mitchell was, more or less, a statue for the Eagles. He was the MOP of the title game as he threw for 302 yards and 3 TDs. In 2011 he threw for 4,009 yards and 33 TDs. He was named Big Sky OPOY, 7 All American teams, and the QB of the year by TSN, AFCA, Walter Camp foundation, AP, Phil Steele and Beyond Sports College Network. In his two years at EWU we went 618-1008 (61.3%) for 7,505 yards 70 TD to 28 INT. He had 113 career rushes for -98 yards, so I'd assume the extreme majority of those were sacks.

                      Villanova 2009:
                      Chris Whitney completed 65% of his passes (159-247) for 18 TD to just 5 INT. Taking sacks out, Whitney ran 173 times for 1,146 yards. Probably as close to a running QB as there was.

                      Richmond 2008:
                      Eric Ward completed 65% of his passes (230-359) for 17 TD to 7 INT. Taking sacks out he ran 120 times on the year for 598 yards

                      App State 2006 & 2007:
                      Everyone thinks Armonti was a runner. He could, and did run, very well. His passing was greatly under valued. 2007 was the only year he was able to be considered a runner with 237 rush attempts. His other three year he threw 274, 306, and 378 passes and completed 67% of those passes. Edwards is the definition of a passer who can run like a mother f-er.


                      Maybe that's what we have in Keller. If we get an Armonti Edwards clone, then I'll take it. If we are going to be a slightly better passing Rennie or Bailey, I take a hard pass. I'd even pass on Chris Whitney from Villanova in 09. Whitney played well, but it was the defense that won that title. Only 2 times did they give up more than 21. They gave up 14.1 points per game, 2.3 yards per carry, and just 249 through the air per game. Whitney averaged 145 passing per game with 65 on the ground per game. That's not even Aaron Bailey total yardage numbers. Whitney's numbers are also filtered to only 2 WR - Matt Szczur and Brandyn Harvey. They had 103 of his 159 completions. No other person had more than 17. Looking at his numbers is like looking at Bailey, if Bailey could completed 2 more passes per game - 11-16, 3-7, 7-11, 10-13, 10-18, 11-16, 7-20....Meanwhile you had an offense total up 4,013 yards rushing with 3 people with at least 100 caries....

                      Give me a true pocket guy with the ability to move if he has too over a guy that can move that has to learn how to sit and be comfortable in a pocket. If you get to your sophomore year of college and aren't comfortable in the pocket is isn't going to happen. Fight or flight kicks and and knowing the ability to scramble is there becomes a crutch that is impossible to overcome.
                      Last edited by claw; 02-06-2017, 09:40 AM.

                      Comment


                      • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                        Appears to be a Big difference in touch, mechanics , accuracy, and checking down routes between him and the Sullivan kid, hopefully either Sullivan can bulk up a ton or Keller can improve his football passing skills. One is a very skilled passing QB but is smaller, and One is Big, Athletic but not a true passer,, We will have two years with Dunne to see what develops.

                        Comment


                        • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                          Originally posted by claw View Post
                          Carnes and Bailey had zero passing ability, so that's not saying much. Rennie simply didn't have the arm strength/control.

                          Almost never does a run first QB win at the FCS level.

                          Look at the champions
                          JMU 2016:
                          Bryan ScHore played 14 games, completed 73% of his passes (217-297) for 3,002 yards 29 TD to 6 INT. Yes, he could run but it wasn't his primary move. Taking out sacks he ran 106 times for about 840 yards and 10 TDs. He was the most run heavy QB to win a title since 09

                          NDSU 2011-2015:
                          We all know about Wentz and Jensen (even stick) Could move if had too, and were good at it, but weren't runners.

                          EWU 2010:
                          Bo Levi Mitchell was, more or less, a statue for the Eagles. He was the MOP of the title game as he threw for 302 yards and 3 TDs. In 2011 he threw for 4,009 yards and 33 TDs. He was named Big Sky OPOY, 7 All American teams, and the QB of the year by TSN, AFCA, Walter Camp foundation, AP, Phil Steele and Beyond Sports College Network. In his two years at EWU we went 618-1008 (61.3%) for 7,505 yards 70 TD to 28 INT. He had 113 career rushes for -98 yards, so I'd assume the extreme majority of those were sacks.

                          Villanova 2009:
                          Chris Whitney completed 65% of his passes (159-247) for 18 TD to just 5 INT. Taking sacks out, Whitney ran 173 times for 1,146 yards. Probably as close to a running QB as there was.

                          Richmond 2008:
                          Eric Ward completed 65% of his passes (230-359) for 17 TD to 7 INT. Taking sacks out he ran 120 times on the year for 598 yards

                          App State 2006 & 2007:
                          Everyone thinks Armonti was a runner. He could, and did run, very well. His passing was greatly under valued. 2007 was the only year he was able to be considered a runner with 237 rush attempts. His other three year he threw 274, 306, and 378 passes and completed 67% of those passes. Edwards is the definition of a passer who can run like a mother f-er.


                          Maybe that's what we have in Keller. If we get an Armonti Edwards clone, then I'll take it. If we are going to be a slightly better passing Rennie or Bailey, I take a hard pass. I'd even pass on Chris Whitney from Villanova in 09. Whitney played well, but it was the defense that won that title. Only 2 times did they give up more than 21. They gave up 14.1 points per game, 2.3 yards per carry, and just 249 through the air per game. Whitney averaged 145 passing per game with 65 on the ground per game. That's not even Aaron Bailey total yardage numbers. Whitney's numbers are also filtered to only 2 WR - Matt Szczur and Brandyn Harvey. They had 103 of his 159 completions. No other person had more than 17. Looking at his numbers is like looking at Bailey, if Bailey could completed 2 more passes per game - 11-16, 3-7, 7-11, 10-13, 10-18, 11-16, 7-20....Meanwhile you had an offense total up 4,013 yards rushing with 3 people with at least 100 caries....

                          Give me a true pocket guy with the ability to move if he has too over a guy that can move that has to learn how to sit and be comfortable in a pocket. If you get to your sophomore year of college and aren't comfortable in the pocket is isn't going to happen. Fight or flight kicks and and knowing the ability to scramble is there becomes a crutch that is impossible to overcome.
                          Great post...factual..can't argue with this info. It is proven that you need a QB to make all the throws..the simple throws (screens, bubble passes, back shoulder, sideline routes, hitches etc...not just low % throws)
                          "Give a cheer Ho, the purple and the gold!!"

                          Comment


                          • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                            Originally posted by Purpledog View Post
                            Appears to be a Big difference in touch, mechanics , accuracy, and checking down routes between him and the Sullivan kid, hopefully either Sullivan can bulk up a ton or Keller can improve his football passing skills. One is a very skilled passing QB but is smaller, and One is Big, Athletic but not a true passer,, We will have two years with Dunne to see what develops.
                            Yup. I hope like hell I'm wrong. Believe it or not, I hope I'm wrong probably 95% of the time. I just see how effortless Sullivan looks at making reads and throwing the ball on a pinpoint laser trajectory and then the little bit I see of Keller and it's not that and it worries me about sticking with the same crap we've been running. Average, at best, passer, with the ability to run but not enough passing skills to open up the run game for them.

                            Prove me wrong Jacob. I'll be first in line for my plate of crow when you do.
                            Last edited by claw; 02-06-2017, 10:31 AM.

                            Comment


                            • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                              I enjoy reading posts about which QB has the best throwing touch!

                              Comment


                              • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                                Originally posted by claw View Post
                                Carnes and Bailey had zero passing ability, so that's not saying much. Rennie simply didn't have the arm strength/control.

                                Almost never does a run first QB win at the FCS level.

                                Look at the champions
                                JMU 2016:
                                Bryan ScHore played 14 games, completed 73% of his passes (217-297) for 3,002 yards 29 TD to 6 INT. Yes, he could run but it wasn't his primary move. Taking out sacks he ran 106 times for about 840 yards and 10 TDs. He was the most run heavy QB to win a title since 09

                                NDSU 2011-2015:
                                We all know about Wentz and Jensen (even stick) Could move if had too, and were good at it, but weren't runners.

                                EWU 2010:
                                Bo Levi Mitchell was, more or less, a statue for the Eagles. He was the MOP of the title game as he threw for 302 yards and 3 TDs. In 2011 he threw for 4,009 yards and 33 TDs. He was named Big Sky OPOY, 7 All American teams, and the QB of the year by TSN, AFCA, Walter Camp foundation, AP, Phil Steele and Beyond Sports College Network. In his two years at EWU we went 618-1008 (61.3%) for 7,505 yards 70 TD to 28 INT. He had 113 career rushes for -98 yards, so I'd assume the extreme majority of those were sacks.

                                Villanova 2009:
                                Chris Whitney completed 65% of his passes (159-247) for 18 TD to just 5 INT. Taking sacks out, Whitney ran 173 times for 1,146 yards. Probably as close to a running QB as there was.

                                Richmond 2008:
                                Eric Ward completed 65% of his passes (230-359) for 17 TD to 7 INT. Taking sacks out he ran 120 times on the year for 598 yards

                                App State 2006 & 2007:
                                Everyone thinks Armonti was a runner. He could, and did run, very well. His passing was greatly under valued. 2007 was the only year he was able to be considered a runner with 237 rush attempts. His other three year he threw 274, 306, and 378 passes and completed 67% of those passes. Edwards is the definition of a passer who can run like a mother f-er.


                                Maybe that's what we have in Keller. If we get an Armonti Edwards clone, then I'll take it. If we are going to be a slightly better passing Rennie or Bailey, I take a hard pass. I'd even pass on Chris Whitney from Villanova in 09. Whitney played well, but it was the defense that won that title. Only 2 times did they give up more than 21. They gave up 14.1 points per game, 2.3 yards per carry, and just 249 through the air per game. Whitney averaged 145 passing per game with 65 on the ground per game. That's not even Aaron Bailey total yardage numbers. Whitney's numbers are also filtered to only 2 WR - Matt Szczur and Brandyn Harvey. They had 103 of his 159 completions. No other person had more than 17. Looking at his numbers is like looking at Bailey, if Bailey could completed 2 more passes per game - 11-16, 3-7, 7-11, 10-13, 10-18, 11-16, 7-20....Meanwhile you had an offense total up 4,013 yards rushing with 3 people with at least 100 caries....

                                Give me a true pocket guy with the ability to move if he has too over a guy that can move that has to learn how to sit and be comfortable in a pocket. If you get to your sophomore year of college and aren't comfortable in the pocket is isn't going to happen. Fight or flight kicks and and knowing the ability to scramble is there becomes a crutch that is impossible to overcome.
                                Good post. Also, a running QB is bound to get dinged up enough with injuries over the season that his effectiveness becomes limited. Rennie was a great example. Early in the season, he was a real weapon, but that decreased as wear and tear piled up. Farley seems to look at only the upside with this type of player, without throwing some realism into his thinking. You expose your QB to hits, and it lowers his shelf life. That's one of Newton's Laws of Physics.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X