WWW.PANTHERNATION.COM
GO PANTHERS!
welcome

Welcome to the best UNI Panther forum on the net!

Become a PN Supporting Member! Get exclusive access to the Panther Den forum and more. Click here for info.

30-minute show exclusively highlighting UNI Athletics. Click here for info.

  • You need to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed.
  • To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
  • If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the help page by clicking this link.
  • If you have any questions please use the Contact Us form.
This website is not affiliated with the University of Northern Iowa or the UNI Panther Athletic Program.

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Class of 2017--Football Recruits

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by ubuntuCAT View Post
    Doesn't UNI rarely if ever use all 63 scholarships anyway?


    Typically uni goes into fall camp with ~3 to 5 open rides.

    Comment


    • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

      I believe we don't issue the full amount of scholarships for one simple reason -- MONEY! A few years back I worked on the fundraising for the PSC. At that time, the cost of scholarships was over 3 million, and PSC raised only $1.3 million. So, you see, Panther fans-----we need more support for the PSC!! Pass the word, and join up!!! And if you already belong, please consider raising your contribution.

      Comment


      • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

        an elite program would not offer or should not offer a kid simply because his dad. Now I am shocked and find it odd we never even reached out, I don't think anyone is going to try and argue that. We should have at a minimum probably reached out and offered a walk on spot. The only thing to argue is how can EVERY single program not offer and ppl think he is worth a scholarship? too many ppl get caught up with this idea that because his dad made the impossible happen his son can somehow do something similar. he broke records and still, not a single school cared to offer a full ride. That should make it pretty clear that there is something going on that us fans don't know about. if he was good enough with stats like that at least one school would have offered.

        Comment


        • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

          Originally posted by unipanther2154 View Post
          you can be that guy because clearly you think a highly of your football knowledge. i just don't get how someone with "football knowledge" can say stats cant sometimes be misleading with regards to a players potential.

          the 12k was obvious sarcasm. pointing out that stats don't necessarily mean everything when in that system. I really don't see how this is hard to understand. The ppl on here who think this kid deserves an offer know more than every single FCS and FBS program?? how can ppl not understand why he wasn't offered if literally no one else was interested. If your point is just to get Kurt involved then I can understand that more, however I don't think that really matters with his involvement with the NFL network. doesn't really have a lot of time to come to games...
          Can't understand why he wasn't offered if litterly no one else was interested?,,,??? Yes it is hard to undersand, why not even a PWO. Farley went after that QB Keller hard, and there was literally hardly anyone else intersted in him. Why is that? Farley evidently sees something despite the lack of recruitment pursuit for football for Keller. And when you look at more than just stats, and look at video, the Warner kid appears more talented and has more upside at the WR position than Keller has at the QB position?? So yes, it is hard to understand for some.

          Comment


          • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

            Not really that difficult. He has two walk on offers. Nebraska, due only as his hs coach now works there and local ASU. No one offered a scholarship and two walk on opportunities due to relationships. Played in a gimmick system and rang up hs stats. You do the math

            Comment


            • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

              ------Not really that difficult. He has two walk on offers. Nebraska, due only as his hs coach now works there and local ASU. No one offered a scholarship and two walk on opportunities due to relationships. Played in a gimmick system and rang up hs stats. You do the math, -----

              Ok, did the math, the "system" may have been an advantage for him but there are still 11 guys that had to play defense each week that most likely practiced and prepared for that "system", I was also including my questioning why no PWO from his highlight video as well, and the fact that Farley went hard after another recruit offering a full ride to a QB, who had very little interest from other programs. So the logic of no other programs interested is also what I was questioning.

              Comment


              • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                Originally posted by Purpledog View Post
                And when you look at more than just stats, and look at video, the Warner kid appears more talented and has more upside at the WR position than Keller has at the QB position?? So yes, it is hard to understand for some.
                Not sure I could sign up for that analysis.

                I believe KW can play...But not sure I've seen/heard anything to tell me he's more talented than Keller. Keller's senior year tape looks pretty good and he's a big kid who was athletic enough to get multiple D1 hoops offers.
                Winning is more fun than losing.

                Comment


                • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                  Originally posted by Blue42 View Post
                  Not sure I could sign up for that analysis.

                  I believe KW can play...But not sure I've seen/heard anything to tell me he's more talented than Keller. Keller's senior year tape looks pretty good and he's a big kid who was athletic enough to get multiple D1 hoops offers.
                  No, I agree , Keller very athletic and talented, I was just saying and being specific for his position, if that's what Farley was going after him for QB. I think a kid like Keller will have a great impact somewhere on the team. And, Yes multiple HOOPS offer, again I was just comparing that he also had little Football interest yet strong recruiting effort by Farley. Not saying the kid is bad, just my comparison if strictly looking at position, mechanics, etc.

                  Comment


                  • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                    Originally posted by Purpledog View Post
                    ------Not really that difficult. He has two walk on offers. Nebraska, due only as his hs coach now works there and local ASU. No one offered a scholarship and two walk on opportunities due to relationships. Played in a gimmick system and rang up hs stats. You do the math, -----

                    Ok, did the math, the "system" may have been an advantage for him but there are still 11 guys that had to play defense each week that most likely practiced and prepared for that "system", I was also including my questioning why no PWO from his highlight video as well, and the fact that Farley went hard after another recruit offering a full ride to a QB, who had very little interest from other programs. So the logic of no other programs interested is also what I was questioning.
                    if Farley is missing the boat then you can add in the other 600 or so schools that have football programs. Should we have offered him a chance to walk-on? Hell yes. Scholarship? No, absolutely not. It's not like Farley is averse to legacy recruits either. He has had a slew of them including now. All signs point to this kid prospering in high school due to: dad, system, gimmick offense, high school stats. If he was "all that", he'd have offers galore.

                    Comment


                    • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                      Originally posted by Mudrafan View Post
                      if Farley is missing the boat then you can add in the other 600 or so schools that have football programs. Should we have offered him a chance to walk-on? Hell yes. Scholarship? No, absolutely not. It's not like Farley is averse to legacy recruits either. He has had a slew of them including now. All signs point to this kid prospering in high school due to: dad, system, gimmick offense, high school stats. If he was "all that", he'd have offers galore.
                      Oh boy, I was just agreeing that a PWO wouldn't have done any harm. Offers galore? Lol. Ok. I guess Farley and other schools never make mistakes with highly recruited players (Bailey) or players with little to no other offers. DJ had very limited recruitment opportunity, he turned out ok despite no offers galore,

                      Comment


                      • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                        Originally posted by Purpledog View Post
                        Oh boy, I was just agreeing that a PWO wouldn't have done any harm. Offers galore? Lol. Ok. I guess Farley and other schools never make mistakes with highly recruited players (Bailey) or players with little to no other offers. DJ had very limited recruitment opportunity, he turned out ok despite no offers galore,
                        you are generalizing. This Warner kid not only had no offers at the FBS or FCS level...despite all the hs stats & accolades...he also had zero walk-on offers until only recently. One...the local school that is crawling in P12 money & Nebraska where his hs coach went to. In other words...he got damn lucky. Johnson had offers out of high school. They may not have been FBS offers, but he certainly had multiple FCS offers. To compare Kade Warner to Johnson is a huge joke. Yes, coaches make mistakes. If all of them miss on Kade then they do, but it is highly unlikely that every single one will. Like I said over & over, Farley should have offered him a walk-on red carpet. Didn't happen. We don't all know the reasons, but it may have something to do with our beloved program being strapped for cash. They also just went through nearly an entire coaching overhaul, the retirement of a coach that is a legend in the program & in the middle of signing day & upcoming spring ball. Oh...and a new President.

                        Comment


                        • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                          [QUOTE=Purpledog;455169]Oh boy, I was just agreeing that a PWO wouldn't have done any harm. Offers galore? Lol. Ok. I guess Farley and other schools never make mistakes with highly recruited players (Bailey) or players with little to no other offers. DJ had very limited recruitment opportunity, he turned out ok despite no offers galore,[/QUOTE

                          DJ had offers..... Warner.....nope
                          DJ stats were ok....Warner had HUGE numbers. Not really something that happens to someone "under recruited"
                          DJ type players Don't happen that often. And when I say that often it's really, really rare. So yeah, good comparison.

                          No one disagrees that he shouldn't have been given a walk on spot but I seriously don't understand how anyone can act like it's some guarantee this kid is D1 level when even small FCS schools desperate for talent surrounding him don't even come around. Is logic really that hard to come by these days? Players who throw up these stats don't get under looked for no reason. It's not like he's playing 8 man or single A.

                          Comment


                          • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                            Something that I don't believe that has been directly mentioned - the FB staff can get two or three, maybe four Iowa players for roughly the same cost as an out of state player. Also, maybe our receiver corp is stocked at this point, needing more help elsewhere?

                            Honestly, only a couple people really know.

                            Comment


                            • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                              Originally posted by Trapped in California View Post
                              Something that I don't believe that has been directly mentioned - the FB staff can get two or three, maybe four Iowa players for roughly the same cost as an out of state player. Also, maybe our receiver corp is stocked at this point, needing more help elsewhere?

                              Honestly, only a couple people really know.

                              Is this really the way it works? The internal transfer for out of state athletes is at out of state tuition rates? I thought all tuition was at in-state rates, but now that you mention it, I don't have any evidence to back up that thought. Hopefully, they find a way to "establish residency" early in the athlete's career so that they can use in-state tuition for the latter years, if not right from the outset.

                              Comment


                              • Re: Class of 2017--Football Recruits

                                The way the State of Iowa handles residency is pretty tough, relatively speaking. You need to be under 6 hours of school for a year, while living in state (presumably working). Otherwise their would be even more Chicago students at AIB East.

                                Yes, UNI out of state athletes are charged full freight for tuition. I know it's a left pocket right pocket discussion within the university, but it is in place. The athletic department budget bears that cost.

                                The reality is that most out of state players are not coming here without that tuition cost being nearly or wholly covered.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X