Originally posted by BCPanther
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Official 2018 Panther Basketball Recruit List
Collapse
X
-
I was 100% in the Chatman camp until recently, but Braun's 2018 clips are more impressive than his 2017 ones. Braun is taller, looks to be more of a rim protector on D and surely has a better outside jumper than Sy. However, Sy has played with (and against) better competition and his mid range game would be more complimentary to our roster than Braun's, IMO (Braun and Biggie look like clones to me). Plus, Sy can conceivably guard 3-4 positions, and outside of being a shot blocker I don't see much in Braun's highlights that lend to him being a quality defender, much less a versatile one. This could be the weakness of our recent recruiting commits (defense) and maybe by design with our embarrassing offense the last two seasons, but you know playing time will come down to ability to guard and Sy could be that glue guy for us on D and rebounding (both ends). I'm still on the Sy bandwagon (if I had to choose between them) but I'm more impressed with Braun today than I was previously, so I'd be pleased with either.
-
Originally posted by orangetennis View Post
Wish we had more recent video of Croft, his HS clips aren't spectacular. He's only 6'1'' very thin with a low release point, and the video was against poor competition. On the plus side he's a lefty, looked like a competent passer and ball handler and featured a nice floater.
He sure looks impressive to me. Only 6'1"? Juwan was 5'11"
He's got a good looking shot, very quick, athletic and a huge scorer which this team needs.
Having a point guard like Juwan who can't shoot at all was devastating last year.
He does look a little skinny, but he seems way more impressive than some of more recent JUCO adds like Hunter or Arias Austin.
Comment
-
The release point is not low any more. Based on the video of ICCC games I've seen.Originally posted by orangetennis View Post
Wish we had more recent video of Croft, his HS clips aren't spectacular. He's only 6'1'' very thin with a low release point, and the video was against poor competition. On the plus side he's a lefty, looked like a competent passer and ball handler and featured a nice floater.Winning is more fun than losing.
Comment
-
His shot does look better here, so that's good. 6'1'' isn't any taller just because Juwan was 5'11'', but he does look fairly long, so maybe he'll play more like a 6'3'' guy.Originally posted by OhNewby View Post
He sure looks impressive to me. Only 6'1"? Juwan was 5'11"
He's got a good looking shot, very quick, athletic and a huge scorer which this team needs.
Having a point guard like Juwan who can't shoot at all was devastating last year.
He does look a little skinny, but he seems way more impressive than some of more recent JUCO adds like Hunter or Arias Austin.
Comment
-
Larson size wasn’t an issue. Larson very low shooting percent wasn’t an issue.Originally posted by orangetennis View Post
Wish we had more recent video of Croft, his HS clips aren't spectacular. He's only 6'1'' very thin with a low release point, and the video was against poor competition. On the plus side he's a lefty, looked like a competent passer and ball handler and featured a nice floater.
Croft size (bigger than Larson) an issue. Croft has a low release but shoots really well but it’s an issue.
Really people?
Croft is a JUCO All American and scores over 1600 points in two seasons at ICCC. Juwan had 281 in 2 at UNI. Larson would need a decade to score 1600 at the rate he scored at.
Comment
-
Sy isn’t coming here. Get off that train.Originally posted by orangetennis View Post
I was 100% in the Chatman camp until recently, but Braun's 2018 clips are more impressive than his 2017 ones. Braun is taller, looks to be more of a rim protector on D and surely has a better outside jumper than Sy. However, Sy has played with (and against) better competition and his mid range game would be more complimentary to our roster than Braun's, IMO (Braun and Biggie look like clones to me). Plus, Sy can conceivably guard 3-4 positions, and outside of being a shot blocker I don't see much in Braun's highlights that lend to him being a quality defender, much less a versatile one. This could be the weakness of our recent recruiting commits (defense) and maybe by design with our embarrassing offense the last two seasons, but you know playing time will come down to ability to guard and Sy could be that glue guy for us on D and rebounding (both ends). I'm still on the Sy bandwagon (if I had to choose between them) but I'm more impressed with Braun today than I was previously, so I'd be pleased with either.
Parker is 6’10. Shoots 40+ % from outside. Changes direction very well. Attacks the rim like it stole money from him. Watch his 2018 film from Hudl. Kid is a monster.
IDGAF if he and Shannon (I will never use biggie...probably) are the same player. They are miles and miles ahead of where McDonnell is. Parker and Shannon at the same time allows Parker to RS and develop bulk. The traditional inside post player is dead in college. Players like Shandon and Parker are where it’s going. Parker has plenty of tape of him posting up.
Do we need more 3s right now given what we have on the roster?
A rotation of Austin, Shandon, Parker, McDonnell and James Betz - whom people are forgetting is an athletic freak - is a very very very scary things for other teams to prep for.
Parkers brother already has a couple MVC offers. Get them both in here. Parker’s younger brother takes Crofts spot after he graduates.
Comment
-
One thing we struggled a lot with last season is turnovers. Croft averaged right at 2 TO/game running the point in his 2 years at ICCC. I'd take that in a heartbeat next year. Granted, he won't be starting.Last edited by CyCarp; 04-11-2018, 09:50 PM.To avoid confusion - my username is baseball (Cy Young award) related, NOT for the Cyclones.
Comment
-
I guess Isaiah Brown and Pickford don’t l exist anymore...?Originally posted by OhNewby View PostFor those who think we need Braun over Sy, I'll ask who is going to guard Valley players like Yarborough or Fayne next year? Luke? I like Luke, but no way. We need a strong 3-4 like Sy or we're in trouble, IMO.
also Fayne is 6’9-6’10 200-210 LBs. No damn way Sy would be able to take that as a true freshman anyway.
Comment
-
Christian Braun will be a Senior next year, Croft still has 2 years to play. Unless I'm missing something, there's no ride open in Christian's class, right now at least.Originally posted by clenz View PostSy isn’t coming here. Get off that train.
Parker is 6’10. Shoots 40+ % from outside. Changes direction very well. Attacks the rim like it stole money from him. Watch his 2018 film from Hudl. Kid is a monster.
IDGAF if he and Shannon (I will never use biggie...probably) are the same player. They are miles and miles ahead of where McDonnell is. Parker and Shannon at the same time allows Parker to RS and develop bulk. The traditional inside post player is dead in college. Players like Shandon and Parker are where it’s going. Parker has plenty of tape of him posting up.
Do we need more 3s right now given what we have on the roster?
A rotation of Austin, Shandon, Parker, McDonnell and James Betz - whom people are forgetting is an athletic freak - is a very very very scary things for other teams to prep for.
Parkers brother already has a couple MVC offers. Get them both in here. Parker’s younger brother takes Crofts spot after he graduates.To avoid confusion - my username is baseball (Cy Young award) related, NOT for the Cyclones.
Comment
-
Interesting...he averaged more TO's per game than the guy who left and it was against a lower level of competition and you are ecstatic for that to happen here. Hard to determine what this board wants. You all are very selective in what is important and with no consistency whatsoever.Originally posted by CyCarp View PostOne thing we struggled a lot with last season is turnovers. Croft averaged right at 2 TO/game rubbing the point in his 2 years at ICCC. I'd take that in a heartbeat next year. Granted, he won't be starting.
Comment
-
I was never on Larson's bandwagon, that was other posters.Originally posted by clenz View Post
Larson size wasn’t an issue. Larson very low shooting percent wasn’t an issue.
Croft size (bigger than Larson) an issue. Croft has a low release but shoots really well but it’s an issue.
Really people?
Croft is a JUCO All American and scores over 1600 points in two seasons at ICCC. Juwan had 281 in 2 at UNI. Larson would need a decade to score 1600 at the rate he scored at.
Comment
-
I'm curious what has changed from maybe 10 days ago when I believe you and BC were both commenting on your confidence he was coming here due to the people you follow on twitter? The two of you went from high levels of confidence to zero confidence. Maybe you can elaborate?Originally posted by clenz View PostSy isn’t coming here. Get off that train.
Parker is 6’10. Shoots 40+ % from outside. Changes direction very well. Attacks the rim like it stole money from him. Watch his 2018 film from Hudl. Kid is a monster.
IDGAF if he and Shannon (I will never use biggie...probably) are the same player. They are miles and miles ahead of where McDonnell is. Parker and Shannon at the same time allows Parker to RS and develop bulk. The traditional inside post player is dead in college. Players like Shandon and Parker are where it’s going. Parker has plenty of tape of him posting up.
Do we need more 3s right now given what we have on the roster?
A rotation of Austin, Shandon, Parker, McDonnell and James Betz - whom people are forgetting is an athletic freak - is a very very very scary things for other teams to prep for.
Parkers brother already has a couple MVC offers. Get them both in here. Parker’s younger brother takes Crofts spot after he graduates.
- Likes 1
Comment
-
No. Life. Stuff. Things.Originally posted by hoopfan View PostMaybe you can elaborate?
maybe he does. Don’t count on it. Maybe he does.
im not at zero, but I’m not high. Things I’ve heard shifted. Things I’ve seen shifted. Behaviors and actions have shifted. It’s still snowing and it’s mid April. maybe I’m wrong. Maybe I misunderstood this few things. I think he’d be a terrific addition and play a big role for this team. As things has gone on I’ve just gotten a turn in my gut feeling on it.
I really, really, like Braun. I think he’s the type of combo post player that can make a big difference. Reminds me of Tut watching his tape.Last edited by clenz; 04-11-2018, 10:07 PM.
Comment



Comment